Pardons Now Go to Whoever Knows the President. Here’s How That Happened.

Since 1891, career Justice Department lawyers have reviewed pardon requests before they reach the president. Presidents of both parties have chipped away at that check, and in the last two years it has been taken apart.

· 10 min read

The president’s pardon power is one of the few in the Constitution with almost no limits. A president can’t pardon state crimes or undo an impeachment, and that’s about it. There’s no Senate vote and no court review, and a president doesn’t have to explain a pardon to anyone.

What kept that power in check for more than a century wasn’t the law. It was a process: a small office of career lawyers at the Justice Department who reviewed every request and told the president whether it deserved mercy. Presidents of both parties have chipped away at that process for decades. In the last two years, it has been taken apart.

What the founders intended

The power comes from one line in Article II: the president “shall have Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.”

Alexander Hamilton made the case for it in Federalist No. 74. He gave two reasons. First, criminal law can be harsh, and someone needs to be able to show mercy when a sentence is unjust. Second, during a rebellion, a well-timed offer of pardon can end the fighting. He argued the “benign prerogative of pardoning” should be as unrestricted as possible, and that one person would feel the weight of the decision more than a committee would.

Not everyone agreed. At the Constitutional Convention, George Mason of Virginia warned that a president might use pardons to protect people involved in his own wrongdoing. He asked: “may he not stop inquiry and prevent detection?” The answer from James Madison and others was impeachment. If a president abused the pardon to shield his own circle, Congress could remove him.

So the founders saw the risk. They decided mercy was worth it and trusted impeachment to handle abuse. No president has ever been impeached over a pardon.

The check that actually worked

Impeachment never became the real safeguard. A quieter one did.

Congress created the job that became the Office of the Pardon Attorney in 1891. It’s staffed by career lawyers, not political appointees, and for most of the 20th century nearly every pardon went through it.

The rules are simple and apply to everyone. Under Justice Department guidelines, you generally wait at least five years after your release before applying for a pardon. The office looks at how you’ve lived since, whether you’ve accepted responsibility, and how serious the crime was. It asks the prosecutors and sometimes the judge and victims for their views. Then it sends a recommendation up the chain to the White House.

Presidents have never been required to follow that process. But the process did something the Constitution doesn’t: it made sure someone with no personal stake looked at every case before the president signed. A pardon that skipped it stood out.

How presidents started going around it

Counting pardons doesn’t tell you much. Since Reagan, presidents have granted anywhere from 74 individual pardons (George H.W. Bush) to 396 (Clinton), according to the Justice Department. Biden granted just 80, but among them were his own son and, in his final minutes, his brothers and sister. Trump’s roughly 140 second-term pardons don’t count the 1,500 or so Jan. 6 defendants he pardoned in a single proclamation.

What matters is how many pardons skipped the review. For decades the answer was “a few,” and those few were the ones that caused scandals:

  • Ronald Reagan pardoned two FBI officials convicted of authorizing illegal break-ins during investigations of radical groups in the 1970s.
  • George H.W. Bush pardoned former Defense Secretary Caspar Weinberger and five others in the Iran-Contra affair in 1992. Weinberger’s trial was less than two weeks away. The independent counsel said the pardons completed a six-year cover-up, and Bush himself had been a likely trial witness.
  • Bill Clinton pardoned Marc Rich, a fugitive charged with tax evasion whose ex-wife was a major Democratic donor, along with his own half-brother, Roger. The Rich pardon never went through the pardon office.
  • George W. Bush commuted the prison sentence of Scooter Libby, Vice President Cheney’s chief of staff.
  • Barack Obama commuted Chelsea Manning’s sentence for leaking classified documents and pardoned Gen. James Cartwright for lying to investigators about a leak.

Then the exceptions started to become the pattern. Harvard law professor Jack Goldsmith and Matt Gluck tracked every grant in Trump’s first term and found that only 25 of his 238, or 11 percent, came on the pardon attorney’s recommendation. Most of the rest went to people with a personal or political connection to the president, including Roger Stone, Paul Manafort, Michael Flynn, Steve Bannon and Jared Kushner’s father.

Trump’s first term: most grants skipped the reviewTrump’s 238 first-term pardons and commutationsRecommended by the pardon attorney: 25 (11%)Skipped the review: 213 (89%)25 (11%)Recommended by the pardon attorney213 (89%)Skipped the review
Source: Jack Goldsmith and Matt Gluck, Federal Sentencing Reporter (2021), via Lawfare. Their best estimate from White House statements and Justice Department records.

Preemptive pardons skip the review entirely

Most pardons come after a conviction, which gives the review something to review. A preemptive pardon comes before any charge, and sometimes before any investigation. The Supreme Court has said that’s allowed, and Gerald Ford’s 1974 pardon of Richard Nixon is the most famous example.

Joe Biden took preemptive pardons much further.

In December 2024, he pardoned his son Hunter for any federal crime he “committed or may have committed” over more than a decade, after promising for months that he wouldn’t. In his final hours in office, he preemptively pardoned Dr. Anthony Fauci, retired Gen. Mark Milley, the members and staff of the House Jan. 6 committee, and the police officers who testified to it. Minutes before leaving office, he did the same for his brothers, his sister and their spouses.

Biden said these people had done nothing wrong and were being protected from political revenge. Trump had openly threatened to prosecute some of them, so the worry wasn’t imaginary. But the move had real costs:

  • It treats the justice system as hopelessly political. If a president believes his successor’s Justice Department can’t be trusted, the answer is courts, juries and Congress, not blanket immunity for friends and family.
  • It puts a cloud over the people it protects. The Supreme Court has said accepting a pardon carries an implication of guilt. Fauci, Milley and the committee members say they did nothing wrong, but they’ll never get to clear their names in court.
  • It set a precedent. Once one president preemptively pardons his family and allies, the next one can point to it, and Trump has.

Taking the review process apart

In Trump’s second term, the review process wasn’t just skipped. It was taken apart.

  • In March 2025, the Justice Department fired Pardon Attorney Liz Oyer, a career lawyer. She later told Congress she was fired after refusing to recommend restoring actor Mel Gibson’s gun rights following a domestic violence conviction.
  • The job went to Ed Martin, a political activist who had represented Jan. 6 defendants, and who at first also ran the department’s “Weaponization Working Group” investigating the Biden administration. The pardon attorney had always been a nonpolitical position until then. Martin left in August to do election legal work for Republicans.
  • The White House created a separate “pardon czar” role, outside the Justice Department.
  • In July 2026, the department rejected nearly 6,000 applications in one batch, including more than 2,000 filed before Trump took office.

A Reuters investigation this summer measured the result. It looked at whether people granted clemency met the Justice Department’s long-standing guidelines, like the five-year wait and accepting responsibility:

The mercy track is disappearingShare of clemency recipients who met the Justice Department’s standardsBiden: met the standards, over 99%Biden: didn't meet them, under 1%Bidenover 99% met · under 1% didn’tTrump, 1st term: met the standards, 86%Trump, 1st term: didn't meet them, 14%Trump, 1st term86% met · 14% didn’tTrump, 2nd term: met the standards, 4%Trump, 2nd term: didn't meet them, 96%Trump, 2nd term4% met · 96% didn’tMet the standardsDidn’t meet them
Source: Reuters investigation, June 2026. Standards include a five-year wait after release and accepting responsibility.

That’s a different test from the first-term chart above. Reuters asked whether recipients met the office’s basic rules on paper, not whether the office actually recommended them. That’s why only 14% of Trump’s first-term grants fail it, even though 89% skipped the review: many would have qualified if they’d gone through it.

The Biden figure is low partly because most of his grants were commutations for nonviolent drug offenders, the kind of cases the guidelines were built for. His family and preemptive pardons were exceptions, but they were very visible ones. In Trump’s second term, the exceptions became the rule. Mercy for people who followed the process used to be the point of the pardon. Now it’s the exception.

Reuters also identified more than 110 Trump allies among the people who lobbied the White House for pardons. Instead of a career lawyer reviewing a file, the path to a pardon now runs through people who know the president.

Most of Trump’s second-term pardons weren’t individual cases at all. They came in two mass proclamations for people tied to his own fight over the 2020 election:

Where Trump’s second-term pardons went91% came in two mass pardons for people tied to the 2020 election fightJan. 6 defendants: about 1,500 (87%)2020 alternate electors and allies: 77 (4%)Individual pardons: about 140 (8%)about 1,500 (87%)Jan. 6 defendants77 (4%)2020 alternate electors and alliesabout 140 (8%)Individual pardons
Sources: Justice Department clemency records (individual pardons through Oct. 13, 2026); news reports on the Jan. 20, 2025 and Nov. 7, 2025 proclamations. Jan. 6 figure is approximate and includes about 14 commutations.

Here’s some of what got through once the review was gone:

  • Changpeng Zhao, founder of the crypto exchange Binance, was pardoned in October 2025 after pleading guilty to money laundering violations. He has deep ties to World Liberty Financial, the Trump family’s crypto company, which earned Trump more than $57 million in a single year. An investment fund from the United Arab Emirates used $2 billion of World Liberty’s digital currency to buy a stake in Binance.
  • Paul Walczak, a nursing home executive who pleaded guilty to keeping more than $10 million in his employees’ payroll taxes, was pardoned less than three weeks after his mother attended a $1-million-a-head Trump fundraiser at Mar-a-Lago.
  • Juan Orlando Hernández, former president of Honduras, had been sentenced to 45 years for helping move hundreds of tons of cocaine into the United States. Trump announced the pardon two days before Honduras’ presidential election, alongside his endorsement of Hernández’s party’s candidate.
  • George Santos, the former New York congressman who pleaded guilty to fraud and identity theft, had his sentence commuted after serving less than three months.
  • More than 70 people tied to the 2020 “alternate electors” effort, including Rudy Giuliani and Mark Meadows, were pardoned in November 2025, even though none faced federal charges.

Trump says many of the people he pardoned were targeted by a politicized Biden Justice Department, and some of them probably were treated harshly. But that’s exactly the kind of claim the pardon attorney’s office exists to check. Without it, there’s no way to tell a real injustice from a favor.

The people who pay for this aren’t the famous ones. They’re the thousands of people who filed paperwork, waited out their five years and rebuilt their lives, and who now sit in a backlog while someone with a connection jumps ahead of them.

What I’d change

Presidents should keep the power to show mercy. Hamilton was right that someone needs to be able to fix an unjust sentence. But every pardon should go through an established review that the public can see:

  • One process for everyone. Every request goes to an independent review office run by career lawyers, with published standards. No side doors for family, friends, donors or political allies.
  • A public record. For every pardon, the public should see who asked for it, what the review office recommended, who was paid to lobby for it, and whether the person or family gave money to the president’s campaign or businesses.
  • A written reason. If a president overrules the review office, he should have to explain why, in writing, for everyone to read.
  • An office that can’t be purged. Make the pardon attorney a career job with a fixed term, so the office can give honest advice without fear of being fired.

Congress can require much of this now, especially the disclosure and the protections for the office. Making the review truly mandatory would take a constitutional amendment, because the Supreme Court has held that Congress can’t limit the pardon power itself. That’s hard, but it isn’t impossible if both parties are honest that both have abused it.

Mercy shouldn’t depend on who you know, and right now it does.