A Front Door That Works
At a glance
- A strong border and a working front door go together. One without the other fails.
- Immigrants and their children founded 229 of the Fortune 500, and legal and undocumented immigrants alike pay into Social Security with every paycheck.
- Employers ask for three times the seasonal visas the law allows. Let visas follow the job market.
- Fix the green card line, keep the talent we train, and keep an earned path to citizenship.
“Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
— Emma Lazarus, “The New Colossus,” 1883, inscribed at the Statue of Liberty
Where we stand
Those lines have greeted newcomers in New York Harbor for more than a century. They describe the country I believe in: one confident enough to welcome people who want to work, build, and become Americans.
America is stronger when immigrants are part of our strategy, not an afterthought. That means a border we control and a legal system that actually works. Right now we have neither a front door that opens on time nor a plan for the people already here. This page covers the legal side: how people come here to work, how they become permanent residents, and how they earn citizenship. My immigration overview covers the big picture, and my border security ideas cover the border itself.
What we want to accomplish
- A strong border and a working front door, together. Each one makes the other possible.
- Fix the green card line. Raise the limits Congress set in 1990 and end the per-country caps that make some people wait for generations.
- Guest worker visas that follow the job market. More visas when employers can’t find workers, fewer when unemployment rises, and American workers first every time.
- Keep the talent we train. Graduates of American universities in fields we need should be able to stay and build here.
- An earned path to citizenship. For people who work, pay taxes, stay out of trouble, and wait their turn.
- Congress sets the rules. Legal immigration levels should be decided by votes in Congress, not changed overnight by proclamation.
What we shouldn’t do
- Pretend we must choose between security and immigration. That’s a false choice, and it’s kept Congress stuck for 20 years.
- Shut the front door while saying “get in line.” You can’t tell people to come legally and then close the legal routes.
- Treat immigrant workers as cheap labor to exploit. Every guest worker earns the prevailing wage and pays full payroll taxes, so American workers are never undercut.
- Let the per-country caps stand. No one should be told their wait is longer than a human lifetime because of where they were born.
- Give anyone citizenship for free. It’s earned, with conditions, at the back of the line.
Immigrants built this country
Every generation of Americans has a story about people who arrived with very little and built something lasting.
Immigrants dug the canals and laid the railroads. They worked the mines, the mills, and the farms. In Utah, pioneers who were driven from their homes crossed the plains, and they were followed by Basque sheepherders, Greek and Italian miners in Carbon County, Japanese farmers, Pacific Islanders, and families from Mexico, Bosnia, Somalia, and many other places. They built our towns and filled our congregations.
That story isn’t just history. Immigrants and their children founded 229 of the 2026 Fortune 500, about 46% of the list. Those companies took in about $9.8 trillion in revenue in 2025. Apple, Amazon, Boeing, and Ford are on that list. That count includes companies started by the children of immigrants, which critics argue overstates the immigrant role. Count it however you like, and immigrant families are still at the center of American business.
In Utah, about 395,000 immigrants make up roughly 11% of the population. They’re about 12% of the state’s workforce and fill nearly one in five construction jobs, at a time when we desperately need more homes. They earn here, spend here, and pay taxes here.
Ronald Reagan understood this. In his 1989 farewell address, he said that if America’s shining city needed walls, those walls had doors, and the doors were open to anyone with the will and heart to get here.
A strong border and a working front door go together
The immigration debate is often framed as a choice: security or immigration, enforcement or reform. That’s wrong. Each one depends on the other.
A secure border makes Americans willing to welcome legal immigrants, because they trust the system is in control. A working legal system makes the border easier to secure, because people who can come legally for a job don’t need to sneak across a desert to get one. When the front door is jammed, more people try the windows.
We’ve seen leaders get this right. In 1986, President Reagan signed a law that paired tougher enforcement with legal status for millions of people already here. In 2010, Utah’s business, faith, and political leaders signed the Utah Compact, which called for enforcing the law while keeping families together. In 2013, the U.S. Senate passed a bipartisan bill, 68 to 32, that combined a major investment in border security with an earned path to citizenship and new work visas. The House never voted on it.
That’s still the right model. Today, crossings at the southwest border are at their lowest levels in decades. That’s the moment to fix the legal system, not a reason to keep ignoring it.
Immigrants help keep prices down
Here’s something that doesn’t get said enough: immigrants help fight inflation.
When there aren’t enough workers, businesses compete for the few available by raising pay, and those costs get passed on to customers as higher prices. That’s what happened after the pandemic. When more workers are available, that pressure eases. A 2024 study by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City found that rising immigration helped cool an overheated job market and slowed the runaway wage growth that was feeding prices.
The reverse is happening now. As legal immigration has been cut and enforcement has expanded, prices have jumped fastest in the parts of the economy that depend most on immigrant workers. In the year ending in June 2026, core inflation was 2.6%, but lettuce prices rose about 32% and landscaping about 11%, according to an analysis by economists Robert Lynch and Michael Ettlinger published by the advocacy group America’s Voice. Home health care, construction, and restaurants are feeling the same squeeze.
Ranchers have noticed too. In September 2026, the Oklahoma Cattlemen’s Association, the Kansas Livestock Association, and the Texas Cattle Feeders Association issued a joint statement warning that immigration enforcement sweeps in cattle country were disrupting the beef supply. Their members reported thousands of cattle stuck waiting to ship to processing plants and millions of dollars in lost revenue, and the groups warned the disruptions “will lead to higher beef prices for consumers.” That came with beef already at record highs. The ranchers were clear that they support removing people who are here illegally. Their complaint was that the raids were scaring off the legal, documented, skilled workers who keep the supply chain moving. That’s exactly the point: when the legal system and enforcement don’t work together, everyone pays more at the grocery store.
That’s not an argument for paying anyone less. It’s an argument for having enough workers. Every immigrant worker should be paid fairly and legally. A legal, well-run system is the best protection American workers have, because it ends the shadow economy where dishonest employers pay under the table and undercut everyone else.
To be fair, economists don’t all agree on the wage effects. A major review by the National Academies of Sciences found that immigration’s long-run effect on American wages is very small, but that workers without a high school diploma and earlier immigrants can see some pressure in the short run. That’s a real concern, and it’s why I want visas tied to actual labor shortages, prevailing wage rules, and every employer playing by the same rules.
Immigrants pay into Social Security with every paycheck
Immigrants pay taxes, whether they’re here legally or not. Every paycheck from a legal job carries Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes, and immigrant workers tend to be younger, which means they pay in for decades before they collect anything.
Immigrant households paid nearly $652 billion in federal, state, and local taxes in 2023, according to the American Immigration Council. Back in 2019, the last year with a full breakdown, they paid about $166 billion into Social Security and $45 billion into Medicare. In Utah, immigrants pay about $1.9 billion in federal taxes and $1.2 billion in state and local taxes each year, according to the Vera Institute.
That includes undocumented immigrants. Households headed by undocumented immigrants paid about $89.8 billion in federal, state, and local taxes in 2023, according to the American Immigration Council. Many work on the books using an individual taxpayer number or someone else’s Social Security number, so payroll taxes come out of their checks. The Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy estimates they paid $25.7 billion into Social Security and $6.4 billion into Medicare in 2022, for benefits they’ll never be allowed to collect. They also pay sales taxes on what they buy and property taxes through their rent, like everyone else. And if they could work legally, they’d pay even more, because their wages would rise and more of their pay would be reported.
The government’s own numbers show what happens when immigration falls. In 2026, the Social Security Trustees reported that the program’s long-term shortfall grew from 3.82% to 4.42% of taxable payroll. Lower immigration was one of the biggest reasons, adding 0.21 points to the gap. The retirement trust fund is now projected to run short in late 2032. Fewer workers paying in means less money for the retirees counting on those checks.
The Congressional Budget Office, Congress’s nonpartisan scorekeeper, reached a similar conclusion in 2024. It estimated that the recent rise in immigration would reduce federal deficits by about $0.9 trillion over ten years, because new workers add more in taxes than they cost. CBO also noted that state and local governments bear some costs, like schools, and that its estimates are uncertain. That’s fair, and it’s one more reason to run a legal system that brings in workers in an orderly way.
The legal system is broken
Most Americans assume there’s a line that people can simply wait in. For most would-be immigrants, there isn’t. And for the people who are in line, it barely moves.
The green card limits are from 1990. Congress set the number of employment-based green cards at about 140,000 a year, and that number includes spouses and children. Our economy is more than twice as big now, and the limit hasn’t changed.
The per-country caps create lifetime waits. No country can receive more than 7% of the green cards in a year, so India and China get the same number as Iceland. About 1.2 million people are waiting in the main employment categories, and about 79% of them are from India. The National Foundation for American Policy estimates that an Indian engineer filing in 2026 for an advanced-degree green card could wait 179 years. Many of these people are already here on work visas, paying taxes and raising American-born kids, while their lives stay on hold. The House voted 365 to 65 in 2019 to end the per-country caps. The Senate never finished the job.
Seasonal visas are capped far below demand. The H-2B visa for seasonal jobs like landscaping, resorts, and seafood processing is capped at 66,000 a year by a law from 1990. Employers have asked for an average of about 207,000 workers a year over the past five years.
Farm visas don’t fit year-round farms. The H-2A farm visa has no cap, but it only covers seasonal work. A Utah dairy needs workers every day of the year, so it can’t use it at all. The House has passed bipartisan bills to fix this twice, in 2019 and 2021, and both stalled in the Senate.
Skilled worker visas are a lottery. The H-1B visa for engineers, doctors, and other specialists is capped at 85,000 new visas a year, and in most years far more people apply than that. Winners have long been picked by random lottery instead of by skill or pay.
Legal immigration is being cut, not fixed
Over the last two years, legal immigration has been cut far more sharply than illegal immigration, and almost none of it went through a vote in Congress. According to the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, about 72% of the reduction in immigration under the current administration has come from legal pathways, not illegal crossings.
- Refugees. The refugee cap for 2026 was set at 7,500, the lowest ever. Monthly arrivals fell from 12,518 in December 2024 to 1,341 in March 2026.
- Green cards. In January 2026, the State Department paused immigrant visas for nationals of 75 countries. Immigrant visas issued abroad have fallen by about half.
- Skilled workers. In September 2025, a presidential proclamation added a $100,000 fee to many new H-1B petitions. A federal court ruled in June 2026 that the president lacked the authority to impose it, and the administration responded with a new proclamation in September 2026. H-1B visas have likely fallen by at least 25%.
- Seasonal workers. The administration first announced only 35,000 extra H-2B visas for 2026, about half the usual number, then reversed course after employers pushed back.
Some of these steps were defended as security measures, and vetting matters. But a skilled engineer, a refugee family cleared after years of screening, or a spouse waiting for a green card isn’t the border problem. Cutting the legal routes doesn’t make anyone safer. It just pushes away the people who followed the rules.
Whatever you think of any one of these changes, the bigger problem is how they were made. Congress writes immigration law. Levels that matter this much to our economy shouldn’t swing every time the White House changes hands.
The ideas in detail
1. Fix the green card line
- Raise the employment green card limit to match the size of today’s economy, and stop counting spouses and children against it so each slot goes to a worker.
- End the per-country caps for employment green cards, as the House voted to do in 2019. People should wait based on when they applied, not where they were born.
- Clear the backlog of approved petitions. People who already qualify and are already working here should get their green cards, not wait out their careers.
2. Let guest worker visas follow the job market
- Tie the number of visas to real labor shortages. When unemployment in an industry is low and employers can’t find workers, more visas open. When unemployment rises, fewer do.
- American workers first. Employers must advertise every job to American workers before hiring through a visa.
- Every job pays in. Guest workers earn the prevailing wage and pay full payroll taxes, the same as any American, so no one is undercut.
- Make farm visas work for year-round farms, like Utah’s dairies, with the protections in the bipartisan bills the House already passed.
- Let good guest workers earn a green card. Someone who comes legally, works for years, pays taxes, and follows the law shouldn’t have to leave just as they’ve proven themselves.
3. Keep the talent we train
- A green card for advanced graduates. Foreign students who earn a master’s or Ph.D. from an American university in a field we need should be able to stay, rather than take what they learned to a competitor.
- Pick skilled workers by skill and pay, not by lottery. If there are more H-1B applicants than visas, the highest-skilled, best-paid jobs should go first, and Congress should write that into law so it doesn’t change with every administration.
- Fees set by Congress, in the open. A $100,000 fee that shuts small employers out of the program shouldn’t be imposed by proclamation.
4. An earned path to citizenship
People who have built their lives here, work, pay taxes, and stay out of trouble should be able to earn citizenship, with a fine, a background check, and a place at the back of the line. Dreamers, brought here as children, deserve that chance sooner. My immigration overview lays out the conditions.
5. Congress sets the rules, and keeps the border secure
- Pass a comprehensive bill. Border security, a working legal system, and an earned path to citizenship belong in the same package, the way the Senate did it in 2013.
- Fund the border, the courts, and the visa offices. A legal system that takes years to answer a simple application isn’t a legal system. Enough judges, asylum officers, and visa staff to decide cases in months is part of border security.
- Every employer verifies every hire, once the legal options are there, with a system that’s free and fast for small businesses.
The bottom line
The words on the Statue of Liberty aren’t a policy, but they are a promise. America has kept it by being both a nation of laws and a nation of immigrants. A secure border and a front door that works aren’t opposites. Together, they keep our economy growing, our prices in check, and our Social Security checks coming. Utah has shown the way before. It’s time Congress caught up.
Sources
- National Park Service: “The New Colossus” by Emma Lazarus
- Reagan Foundation: farewell address, 1989
- American Immigration Council: Fortune 500 companies founded by immigrants or their children, 2026
- Center for Immigration Studies: a critique of the immigrant-founded Fortune 500 count
- FWD.us: immigrants in Utah, 2026 (advocacy group)
- Vera Institute: Utah immigrant population profile
- KSL: Utah’s immigrant population and construction jobs
- Congress.gov: S. 744, Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act (2013)
- Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City: rising immigration has helped cool an overheated labor market (2024)
- America’s Voice: “The ICE Tax,” analysis by Robert Lynch and Michael Ettlinger (advocacy group)
- Common Dreams: summary of price increases in immigrant-heavy sectors, June 2026
- Texas Tribune: Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas cattle groups warn ICE operations will raise beef prices
- Associated Press via Anchorage Daily News: ranchers say raids are disrupting the beef supply
- KOKH Oklahoma City: Oklahoma Cattlemen’s Association on supporting ICE while protecting the supply chain
- Washington Center for Equitable Growth: research on immigration, workers, and affordability
- National Academies of Sciences: The Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration (2017)
- Axios: immigrants paid nearly $652 billion in taxes in 2023
- American Immigration Council: taxes paid by undocumented immigrant households, 2023
- Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy: tax payments by undocumented immigrants, 2022
- American Immigration Council: immigrants’ Social Security and Medicare contributions, 2019
- Social Security Administration: 2026 Trustees Report press release
- Social Security Office of the Chief Actuary: reasons for change in the 2026 report
- Congressional Research Service: Social Security, selected findings of the 2026 report
- Congressional Budget Office: effects of the immigration surge on the federal budget (2024)
- National Foundation for American Policy: employment-based green card backlogs, August 2026
- Congressional Research Service: the employment-based immigration backlog
- Siasat/IANS: House vote to end per-country caps and India’s share of the backlog
- Congressional Research Service: the H-2B visa and the statutory cap (2026)
- Bloomberg Law: H-2B demand and the administration’s seasonal visa reversal
- Labor Department: 35,000 supplemental H-2B visas announced for 2026
- Cato Institute: Trump has cut legal immigration more than illegal immigration
- VisaVerge: summary of Cato’s estimate that 72% of reductions targeted legal pathways
- Migration Policy Institute: the 75-country immigrant visa pause and other restrictions
- Nolo: the $100,000 H-1B fee, the court ruling, and the renewed proclamation