Strong at Home, Steady Abroad
At a glance
- Foreign policy reaches Utah fast. 173,000 Utah jobs tie back to defense, and $22.4 billion in Utah exports go to 198 countries.
- Politics should stop at the water’s edge. Foreign policy used to unite Americans. Over the past two decades it has become a wedge issue, and we need to get back to working together.
- Strong at home, true to our friends: a strong economy, honest budgets, and allies who carry their share.
- Congress decides on war, under every president. The Constitution says so, and so do most Americans.
Where we stand
America is safest when it is strong at home and steady abroad. That means a growing economy, a military no one wants to test, friends who trust us, and leaders who tell the truth about where our troops are and why.
Utahns already understand this better than most. Thousands of Utah families send sons and daughters to serve missions in nearly every corner of the world, and they come home speaking the languages and caring about the people there. Hill Air Force Base keeps the planes flying. Utah businesses sell to customers on six continents. We don’t need to be convinced that the world matters to Utah. We need a foreign policy that treats Utah families’ money, safety, and sons and daughters with respect.
There’s an old saying in American politics: politics stops at the water’s edge. For most of the last century, Republicans and Democrats fought hard over taxes and spending at home, then stood together when facing other nations. Over the past two decades or so, we’ve lost that habit. Foreign policy has turned into one more wedge issue, a way to score points against the other party instead of a way to keep the country safe. Our adversaries notice when we’re divided, and our friends wonder whether a promise made by one president will survive the next. We need to get back to the older way of thinking: argue it out at home, vote on it in Congress, then speak to the world with one voice.
This page doesn’t cover every country or every crisis. It lays out the principles that every foreign policy position on this site is built on, so you can see the reasoning before you see the specifics.
What we want to accomplish
The goal is simple: keep America safe, free, and prosperous, with as few wars as possible and no surprises for the people paying the bill.
- Make America strong at home first. A strong economy, honest budgets, and a defense industry that can keep up are what make the rest possible.
- Bring politics back to the water’s edge. Foreign policy should unite Americans, not divide them. Policies built with both parties last; policies built by one party get torn up by the next.
- Keep our word to our friends. Alliances multiply our strength. Allies who can count on us, and who pay their fair share, make war less likely.
- Let Congress decide on war. The Constitution gives that power to the people’s representatives, no matter which party is in the White House.
- Deter wars before we have to fight them. Diplomacy first, strength always, and force as the last resort, with a clear mission and a clear end.
- Trade freely with the world. Customers and partners are better than enemies. Trade with friends, and be tough and targeted with rivals.
- Stand with free people against aggressors. When a bigger country invades a smaller one, the whole world is watching what we do.
- Spend every foreign dollar like it’s our own. Aid and defense dollars should be measured by results, with real oversight.
- Lead with Utah values. Honesty, religious freedom, caring for the stranger, and keeping our word are what make people around the world want to be on our side.
What we shouldn’t do
- Use foreign policy as a wedge to score points against the other party.
- Go to war, or stay in one, without a vote of Congress.
- Treat our alliances like a protection racket, or walk away from friends who stood with us.
- Write blank checks to anyone, without clear goals and someone checking the books.
- Use tariffs as a weapon against our friends.
- Retreat from the world and let China and Russia fill the space we leave.
- Commit our troops to open-ended occupations with no clear mission and no way home.
- Treat dictators and democracies as if they were the same.
Why foreign policy is a Utah issue
Foreign policy can feel far away. It isn’t.
| How the world reaches Utah | The numbers |
|---|---|
| Defense jobs | Defense supports about 173,000 Utah jobs and $22.2 billion of the state’s economy, much of it tied to Hill Air Force Base |
| Hill Air Force Base | The state’s largest single-site employer, with nearly 27,000 employees |
| Exports | $22.4 billion in Utah goods sold to 198 countries, supporting about 73,000 Utah jobs |
| Language skills | The Utah National Guard’s linguists work in more than 50 languages, many learned on missions |
| Gas prices | Six months into the Iran war, gas was more than $1 a gallon higher |
When a war drags on, Utahns feel it at the pump and in the family budget. When a trade fight starts, Utah businesses lose customers. When an ally loses faith in us, the jobs at Hill and across our defense industry depend on whether Washington can be trusted to plan ahead. Foreign policy is kitchen-table policy.
Politics used to stop at the water’s edge
The line comes from Arthur Vandenberg, a Republican senator from Michigan. In 1947 he became chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, with a Democrat, Harry Truman, in the White House. Vandenberg could have spent those years fighting Truman. Instead he worked with him. Together they built the foundations of the free world:
| What they built | Senate vote |
|---|---|
| The Marshall Plan, rebuilding Europe after World War II (1948) | 69–17, with both parties voting yes |
| The North Atlantic Treaty, creating NATO (1949) | 82–13 |
Vandenberg’s point was simple: bipartisan foreign policy puts national security ahead of partisan advantage. Those policies outlasted Truman, Vandenberg, and every president since. NATO is still standing more than 75 years later because both parties built it and both parties owned it.
That habit has faded. Over the past two decades or so, foreign policy has become one more front in the partisan fight. Both parties have done it. Wars, treaties, aid packages, and even intelligence briefings have turned into tests of party loyalty instead of questions about what keeps the country safe.
You can see it in the polling. When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, helping Ukraine had strong support in both parties: 74% of Republicans backed economic aid in March 2022. By February 2024, that had fallen to 40%. By March 2025, there was a 47-point gap between the parties on military aid to Ukraine. The Chicago Council on Global Affairs, which has polled Americans on foreign policy since 1974, says the polarization that has long affected issues at home has now spread to foreign policy. In 2023, the gap between the parties over whether America should take an active part in the world was the largest the Council has ever recorded. The votes in Congress over the Iran war this year have fallen largely along party lines too.
Wedge politics abroad has real costs:
- Promises don’t last. When one party makes a deal alone, the other undoes it as soon as it wins. The 2015 Iran nuclear deal was never approved by Congress, and the United States walked away from it three years later. Whatever you think of that deal, allies and adversaries alike learned that an American commitment might only last until the next election.
- Adversaries exploit the split. Russia, China, and Iran study our politics closely. A divided America is easier to wait out.
- Troops and diplomats get caught in the middle. They serve the whole country, not one party, and they deserve leaders who act like it.
Getting back to the water’s edge doesn’t mean nobody can disagree. It means we debate hard here at home, Congress votes, and then America speaks to the world with one voice. A foreign policy built that way can last longer than one president.
The world right now
A few facts frame where things stand in November 2026.
- Iran. The United States and Israel began strikes on Iran in late February. A ceasefire in April and a June agreement both broke down, and the conflict has settled into recurring fighting. A Pentagon assessment found the munitions used have left strategic shortfalls in our stockpiles and exposed bottlenecks in resupply. Congress never voted to authorize the war, and a November poll found 71% of Americans, including about half of Republicans, want Congress to pass a law ending it.
- Ukraine. Russia’s war is nearly five years old. Russian gains this year have been small, but its demands at the negotiating table haven’t changed, and it keeps striking Ukrainian cities and power plants heading into winter.
- NATO. In 2025, allies pledged to spend 5% of their economies on defense and security by 2035. European allies and Canada raised defense spending by 20% in a single year. That pressure came from Washington, and it worked. Credit where it’s due.
- China and Taiwan. China keeps growing its military and pressuring Taiwan. The U.S. approved its largest arms package for Taiwan ever in late 2025, and both parties have kept the long-standing policy of deterring an attack without picking a fight.
- Foreign aid. USAID was shut down in 2025. Before that, all foreign aid made up about 1% of the federal budget. Most Americans guess it’s around a quarter.
Strength starts at home
No country stays strong abroad while it’s weak at home. Three things matter most.
A strong economy. Our economy pays for our military, attracts allies, and gives other countries a reason to want our friendship. Every policy that grows Utah’s economy also makes America safer.
Honest budgets. We now spend more on interest on the national debt than on our entire military. Debt is a security problem. Money spent on interest is money that can’t go to troops, ships, or veterans. The federal budget ideas lay out how to fix it.
A defense industry that can keep up. A few months of fighting with Iran left gaps in our stockpiles of munitions. If we can’t build fast enough to resupply our own troops, our deterrence is weaker than it looks. Utah already builds much of what keeps the Air Force flying. We should expand that capacity here, with multi-year contracts so companies can plan and hire.
Allies make us stronger, and they should carry their share
America has something China and Russia don’t: dozens of countries that choose to stand with us. That’s a huge advantage. It means we don’t have to fight alone, pay alone, or watch every corner of the world alone.
Alliances only work if they’re fair and if everyone believes in them.
- Fair: for years, many allies spent too little on their own defense. That has changed. Allies have committed to 5%, and Europe and Canada are moving fast. We should hold them to it, every year.
- Believable: an alliance is a promise. If our friends start wondering whether we’ll keep it, they’ll make other plans, and our enemies will start testing us. Keeping our word is cheaper than any war.
Congress decides on war
The Constitution gives Congress, not the president, the power to declare war. The founders did that on purpose. They didn’t want one person deciding to send Americans to fight.
The president can and should respond to a sudden attack. But a sustained war needs the people’s representatives to vote yes, on the record, and to own the decision. That protects our troops too: a war Congress has authorized comes with a mission, a budget, and accountability.
This rule should apply to every president, of either party. A rule that would be right under a president we oppose is right under one we support.
Deter first, fight last
The best war is the one that never starts. Deterrence means being strong enough, and clear enough, that no one thinks attacking us or our friends is worth it.
When force is necessary, Americans deserve straight answers to four questions before our troops go in:
- What is the mission?
- What does winning look like?
- How do we get out?
- How are we paying for it?
If leaders can’t answer those questions, they aren’t ready to send anyone’s son or daughter into harm’s way.
Trade is a tool of peace
Countries that trade with each other have a reason to stay friends. Utah sells goods to nearly 200 countries, and each of those customers is a reason for peace.
We should sign new trade deals with allies, keep markets open, and be tough and targeted with rivals like China in the areas that truly matter: chips, critical minerals, defense supplies, and medicine. Taxing our friends’ goods drives them toward China. The details are in Free Trade, Fair Rules, and No Hidden Taxes.
Stand with free people
When a large country invades a smaller one, every dictator in the world watches to see what happens next. If aggression pays in Europe, it becomes more likely in Asia.
Standing with free people doesn’t mean sending American troops everywhere. Most of the time it means weapons, intelligence, sanctions, and working with allies so they carry most of the load. It also means accountability: inspectors general, clear reporting, and no blank checks.
Every foreign dollar should be accountable
Foreign aid is a tiny part of the budget, and the best of it saves lives and keeps Americans safe. Stopping a disease outbreak overseas is far cheaper than fighting it here. Food and disaster relief build friendships that last for generations. And when America steps back, China steps in.
That doesn’t mean every program worked. Aid should follow the same rule we use everywhere else: pay for results, not programs. Fund what works, cut what doesn’t, and show the public the scorecard.
Lead with Utah values
People around the world don’t just judge America by our military. They judge us by how we act. The values Utahns already live are the ones that win friends:
- Honesty. Tell allies and the American people the truth, even when it’s hard.
- Keeping your word. Treaties and promises mean something.
- Religious freedom. Utah was founded by people fleeing persecution for their faith. Defending the right to worship freely belongs at the center of American foreign policy.
- Caring for the stranger. Utah has welcomed refugees for decades and sends thousands of young people abroad to serve. That spirit is a strength, not a weakness.
The ideas in detail
- Rebuild the bipartisan habit. Regular joint briefings for the leaders of both parties on every major foreign policy decision. Treaties, trade deals, and war authorizations should be built to pass with large majorities from both parties, so they outlast any one president.
- Rebuild the arsenal. Multi-year contracts for munitions and key equipment so companies can plan, hire, and build here, including in Utah. Report stockpile levels to Congress every year.
- Bring war back to Congress. Update the 1973 War Powers Resolution so any sustained use of force needs a vote within a set time, with funding cut off if Congress doesn’t act. Repeal old war authorizations that are no longer in use so they can’t be stretched to cover new wars.
- Hold allies to their pledges. Track allied defense spending every year and publish it. Reward the allies who keep their word with priority on joint production and arms sales.
- Ask the four questions out loud. Before any major deployment, the administration should give Congress a public mission statement, a definition of success, an exit plan, and a cost estimate.
- Pay for wars up front. No more war on the credit card. Major military operations should come with a budget and a plan to pay for it, so the cost doesn’t land on our kids.
- Trade with friends. New trade deals with close allies, and targeted action against China where security is at stake.
- Give smart aid a scorecard. Fund the programs with proven results: disease prevention, disaster relief, and food aid. Publish results by program and end the ones that don’t deliver.
- Make religious freedom a priority. Use trade, aid, and diplomacy to defend people persecuted for their faith.
- Use Utah’s strengths. Recruit returned missionaries and Utah’s language speakers into diplomatic, intelligence, and Guard service, and expand the language programs that feed them.
How these principles shape the other positions
Each foreign policy position on this site starts with these principles. Here’s how they apply to the questions ahead.
| Topic | The question we’ll ask |
|---|---|
| Iran and the Middle East | Did Congress vote? Is there a clear mission and a way out? Can Iran be stopped from ever getting a nuclear weapon without an open-ended war? |
| Israel | How do we stand by a close ally while working toward a lasting peace? |
| Ukraine and Russia | How do we help a friend defend itself, with Europe carrying the larger share, and with full accountability for every dollar? |
| China and Taiwan | How do we deter an attack, protect our supply chains, and keep trading where it’s safe to? |
| NATO and our allies | Are allies keeping their pledges, and are we keeping ours? |
| Foreign aid | Is it saving lives and making Americans safer, and can we show the results? |
| Trade and tariffs | Are we trading freely with friends and being targeted with rivals? (Read the position) |
| Border security | Are we protecting every border with the tools that work? (Read the position) |
Questions people ask
Isn’t this just “America First” with different words?
Putting Americans first is the point of any foreign policy. The question is how. Friends who share the cost of defense, customers who buy our goods, and enemies who are too wary to attack are what keep Americans safe. Going it alone costs more.
Why should Utah care about wars half a world away?
Because Utahns pay for them, at the pump, in taxes, and sometimes with the lives of our sons and daughters. About 173,000 Utah jobs are tied to defense, and Utah businesses sell to almost 200 countries. Foreign policy shows up in Utah family budgets.
Doesn’t “politics stops at the water’s edge” mean nobody can criticize the president?
No. It means the arguing happens here at home, out loud and in Congress, and then the country speaks to the world with one voice. Vandenberg disagreed with Truman plenty. He just didn’t let party politics decide whether America kept its word. That’s also why Congress should vote on war: a real debate and a real vote are how both parties end up owning the decision.
Doesn’t making Congress vote tie the president’s hands?
No. The president can still respond to a sudden attack. What changes is that a long war needs the people’s representatives to vote yes. That’s how the Constitution was written, and a war Congress has approved comes with a clear mission and a budget.
We have a huge debt. Why spend anything on foreign aid?
All of it together was about 1% of the budget. The best programs, like stopping disease outbreaks before they reach us, are some of the cheapest national security we buy. We should keep what works, cut what doesn’t, and publish the results.
Is this aimed at one president?
No. The same rules apply to every president, of either party. Some recent decisions fit these principles, like pushing allies to spend more on defense. Others don’t, like a war Congress never voted on. We’ll say so either way.
The bottom line
America is strongest when it’s strong at home, keeps its word to friends, trades with the world, and lets the people’s representatives decide on war. Above all, it’s strongest when Americans face the world together. Politics should stop at the water’s edge again. Utah families already live by those rules. Washington should too.
Sources
- Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute: Utah’s defense industry supports 173,000 jobs and $22.2 billion in GDP (January 2025)
- Hill Air Force Base: Economic Impact Statement (2024)
- Davis Journal: Defense industry dominates Utah’s federal workers (March 2025)
- Gardner Institute and Zions Bank: Utah International Trade, 2025 (May 2026)
- National Guard Bureau: Utah Guard linguists and the 300th Military Intelligence Brigade (2020)
- U.S. Senate: Arthur H. Vandenberg, “American Foreign Policy” speech (January 10, 1945)
- Voteview: Senate passage of the Economic Cooperation Act (Marshall Plan), 69–17, March 13, 1948
- U.S. Capitol Visitor Center and National Archives: Senate ratifies the North Atlantic Treaty, 82–13, July 21, 1949
- Chicago Council on Global Affairs: Americans endorse U.S. commitment to NATO, though GOP support has dipped (June 2025)
- Chicago Council on Global Affairs: Dwindling GOP support for Ukraine (February 2024)
- Chicago Council on Global Affairs: Rise in Republican support for Ukraine (August 2025)
- Congressional Research Service: U.S. Conflict with Iran (September 2026)
- Al Jazeera: Most Americans want Congress to end the Iran war, Reuters/Ipsos poll (November 2026)
- Al Jazeera: U.S. support for the Iran war falls, Reuters/Ipsos poll (August 2026)
- Institute for the Study of War: Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment (November 2026)
- NATO: Defence investment and NATO’s 5% commitment (June 2026)
- Atlantic Council: NATO defense spending tracker (2026)
- Congressional Research Service: Taiwan: Background and U.S. Relations (October 2026)
- KFF Health Tracking Poll: Public views on foreign aid and global health spending (May 2026)
- Rockefeller Foundation and Echelon Insights: Americans back foreign aid a year after USAID’s end (June 2026)
- House Budget Committee: CBO baseline, interest spending exceeds defense spending (February 2026)
- Constitution Annotated: Article I, Section 8
- Yale Avalon Project: War Powers Resolution of 1973