No Nuclear Iran, No Endless War

At a glance

  • Iran must never get a nuclear weapon. That goal unites both parties, and it should guide everything else.
  • The 2015 deal shrank Iran’s enriched uranium stockpile by 98%. After the U.S. left the deal, Iran built up enough near-weapons-grade uranium for as many as 10 bombs.
  • The war has cost $38 billion in military operations, 18 American lives, and the nation’s steepest gas price jump right here in Utah.
  • Congress should vote to end it, and the next deal should be ratified as a treaty so the next election can’t undo it.

16 min read

Where we stand

Iran must never have a nuclear weapon. Leaders in both parties agree on that, and so do we.

The question is how to make sure of it. We had an answer that was working. The 2015 nuclear deal, negotiated with our closest allies, shrank Iran’s nuclear program and put inspectors inside it every day. When the United States walked away in 2018, Iran rebuilt its program bigger than before, and by 2025 it was closer to a bomb than it had ever been.

Now we’re in a war that Congress never voted on, with no clear end, gas prices at record highs, and inspectors who can’t see what Iran is doing. Bombs can set a nuclear program back. Only a verified agreement can tell us it’s gone.

We believe Congress should do its job: vote to end this war, and back a new deal that our allies help build, inspectors can verify, and the Senate approves as a treaty, so it lasts longer than one presidency.

What we want to accomplish

  1. Iran never gets a nuclear weapon, and we can prove it with inspectors on the ground.
  2. End the war through Congress. No war goes on without a vote of the people’s representatives.
  3. Reopen the Strait of Hormuz and bring gas prices down.
  4. A new deal that lasts, ratified by the Senate with votes from both parties.
  5. Work with our allies, not around them.
  6. Bring our troops home safely and rebuild the weapons stockpiles this war has drained.
  7. Stand with the Iranian people, who have suffered most under their own government.

What we shouldn’t do

  • Let Iran get a bomb. Not now, not after a deal expires, not ever.
  • Fight an open-ended war with no vote, no clear goal, and no way out.
  • Send ground troops into Iran to try to remake the country.
  • Sign another deal that only one party supports, so the next president can tear it up.
  • Trust Iran’s word. Every step must be verified.
  • Turn Iran into another partisan weapon. Keeping a bomb out of Iran’s hands should unite us.

What the 2015 deal did

In 2015, the United States, Britain, France, Germany, China, Russia, and the European Union reached an agreement with Iran called the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. Iran agreed to strict limits on its nuclear program. In return, the world lifted nuclear-related sanctions.

Before the deal, Iran had about 19,000 centrifuges, the machines that enrich uranium, and a stockpile of more than 12,000 kilograms of uranium gas, some of it enriched to nearly 20%. That put Iran two or three months away from having enough material for a bomb.

Here’s what the deal required, and what international inspectors confirmed Iran did:

What Iran agreed to What happened
Ship out its enriched uranium 98% of the stockpile left the country. What remained was capped at 300 kilograms.
Enrich only to 3.67%, the level used for power plants Weapons need about 90%.
Remove two-thirds of its centrifuges More than 13,000 were pulled out and put under watch.
Shut down the plutonium path The core of the Arak reactor was removed and filled with concrete.
Accept inspections The most intrusive inspection system ever negotiated for any country

The result: the time Iran would need to make enough material for one bomb went from two or three months to about a year. Report after report from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), the UN’s nuclear watchdog, found Iran was keeping its side of the deal.

The deal had real flaws, and critics raised fair points. Some limits were set to expire after 10 to 15 years. It didn’t cover Iran’s ballistic missiles or its support for groups like Hezbollah. It unfroze Iranian money held overseas, and critics worried some of it would fund those groups. And it never had support from both parties. All Senate Republicans and four Democrats voted to move forward with rejecting it. It survived only because 42 senators blocked that vote, and the Senate never voted on it as a treaty.

Those were reasons to build on the deal and fix its gaps. They weren’t reasons to throw away the limits that were working.

What happened after we walked away

The United States withdrew from the deal on May 8, 2018, and brought back its sanctions. Our allies who helped negotiate it, Britain, France, and Germany, urged us to stay. Iran kept to the limits for about a year. Then it began breaking them, one step at a time.

When What Iran did
July 2019 Went over the 300-kilogram limit, then raised enrichment from 3.67% to 4.5%
September 2019 Began enriching with advanced centrifuges
January 2021 Restarted enrichment to 20% at its underground Fordow site
April 2021 Began enriching to 60%, a short step from weapons grade
June 2025 Held 440.9 kilograms of 60% uranium
After the deal ended, Iran's near-weapons-grade stockpile soaredIran's uranium enriched to 60%, in kilograms (weapons grade is about 90%)0 kg2016–18 (deal)June 2021: 6.5 kg6.5 kgJune 2021Oct. 2024: 182 kg182 kgOct. 2024Feb. 2025: 275 kg275 kgFeb. 2025May 2025: 408.6 kg408.6 kgMay 2025June 2025: 440.9 kg440.9 kgJune 202542 kg: enough for onebomb if enriched further
Under the 2015 deal, Iran could enrich only to 3.67% and hold no more than 300 kg. Iran began enriching to 60% in April 2021. The June 2025 figure is the IAEA's estimate as of June 13, 2025; inspectors have not been able to verify the stockpile since. Sources: IAEA reports via USIP Iran Primer, Arms Control Association, Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation, and the Associated Press.

By June 2025, the IAEA said Iran’s enriched uranium was 48 times the limit the deal allowed. The head of the IAEA warned that the 60% stockpile alone could be enough for as many as 10 bombs if Iran enriched it further. Experts found Iran had come within days of having enough material for a bomb. Iran also learned to build faster centrifuges, and that know-how can’t be bombed or unlearned.

Iran’s leaders made these choices, and they are responsible for them. But it’s also true that the limits stopped when the deal stopped. If we had stayed in the deal with our allies, Iran’s stockpile would have been capped at 300 kilograms of low-enriched uranium, inspectors would have been watching every day, and we would likely not be at war today.

After Israeli and American strikes on Iran’s nuclear sites in June 2025, Iran stopped letting inspectors into the damaged sites. The IAEA says it has lost track of the stockpile. Nobody outside Iran can say for sure where those 440 kilograms are. In September 2025, Britain, France, and Germany brought back the old UN sanctions on Iran. Russia and China opposed the move.

The war

On February 28, 2026, the United States and Israel began striking Iran. Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, was killed on the first day. Iran answered with missiles and drones aimed at Israel, our Gulf partners, and American bases, and it shut down shipping through the Strait of Hormuz, a route for about a fifth of the world’s oil.

Since then:

  • A ceasefire in April didn’t hold. A U.S. naval blockade followed.
  • A June agreement promised to end the fighting and start talks on the nuclear program. It fell apart within weeks, and fighting resumed in July.
  • 18 American service members have been killed and 824 wounded.
  • The CBO estimates military operations cost $38 billion through August 1. A Pentagon review found we’ve used so many munitions that our stockpiles now fall short, with bottlenecks in building more.
  • Talks continue through Qatar and other mediators, with no breakthrough.

The House has passed three war powers resolutions and the Senate one, but Congress has never voted to authorize this war.

Utah is paying at the pump

Before the war, Utah gas cost about $2.75 a gallon. By early October it hit $4.93. That’s the biggest increase of any state since the war began.

Gas prices since the Iran war beganAverage price of a gallon of regular gasoline, 2026UtahU.S. average$3$4$5MarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovApr. 7: ceasefireJune 17: deal signedJuly 8: deal collapsesU.S., Feb 28: $2.98U.S., Apr 6: $4.06U.S., Apr 30: $4.30U.S., May 15: $4.53U.S., Jun 9: $4.16U.S., Aug 11: $4.01U.S., Oct 6: $4.37U.S., Nov 10: $3.98Utah, Feb 28: $2.75Utah, Apr 6: $4.14Utah, Apr 30: $4.37Utah, May 15: $4.61Utah, Jun 9: $4.44Utah, Aug 11: $4.34Utah, Oct 6: $4.93$2.98about $2.75$4.93$4.37$3.98
Prices on selected dates. Utah's prewar price is approximate, based on AAA's reported $2.18 increase through October 6; a November figure for Utah was not available. Sources: AAA, as reported by the Standard-Examiner, Deseret News, the Salt Lake Tribune, the Washington Examiner, and NPR.

Researchers at Brown University estimate the war has cost Utahns about $860 million in extra gasoline and $530 million in extra diesel. Diesel moves the trucks that stock our stores, so that cost shows up in the price of almost everything. Across the country, higher fuel prices have cost households more than $760 each.

What the Iran war has cost so farBillions of dollars, by type of costExtra fuel costs, U.S. householdsExtra fuel costs, U.S. households: $100 billion$100 billionMilitary operations (CBO)Military operations (CBO): $38 billion$38 billionReplacing munitions usedReplacing munitions used: $21.7 billion$21.7 billionExtra fuel costs, UtahExtra fuel costs, Utah: $1.39 billion$1.39 billion
Fuel costs are Brown University's estimates of extra gasoline and diesel spending compared with a no-war path: $100 billion nationally as of September 7, about $760 per household, and about $1.39 billion in Utah as of early October. Military costs are CBO estimates through August 1, 2026. Sources: Brown University Iran War Energy Cost Tracker; Congressional Budget Office via CRS and Stars and Stripes.

Americans want Congress to act

This war has never had majority support. In polls since mid-March, support has stayed below 40%. In November, 71% of Americans, including 51% of Republicans, said they want Congress to pass a law ending it.

Support for the war never reached 40%Share of Americans who approve of U.S. military action against Iran, 202650%Mar. 13–15: 38%38%Mar. 13–15Mar. 17–19: 37%37%Mar. 17–19Mar. 27–29: 35%35%Mar. 27–29Apr. 3–5: 37%37%Apr. 3–5Apr. 10–12: 36%36%Apr. 10–12Early Aug.: 34%34%Early Aug.Late Aug.: 31%31%Late Aug.November: 71% want Congress to end the war71%Nov.: want Congressto end it
Dark bars: approve of U.S. military action against Iran (Ipsos and Reuters/Ipsos polls). Red bar: a different question, the share who want Congress to pass legislation ending the war, including 51% of Republicans (Reuters/Ipsos, November 6 to 9). Sources: Ipsos topline, April 2026; Reuters/Ipsos via Al Jazeera, August and November 2026.

Utahns feel the same way, with an important twist. In an October Deseret News/Hinckley Institute poll, 52% of Utah voters disapproved of the military action and 41% approved. In August, the same poll found that 56% of Utahns thought the war was justified to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon, yet 56% also wanted the military action to end, and a majority backed more sanctions. Utahns agree on the goal. They doubt this war is the way to reach it.

Why a new deal will be hard

We’re not naive about this. Getting a deal as strong as the 2015 deal will be harder than it was the first time, and maybe harder than the war itself.

  • Trust is gone on both sides. Iran broke its limits and hid its stockpile. We left a deal Iran was keeping, and the June agreement collapsed within weeks. Iran’s leaders now argue that a deal with Washington lasts only until the next president.
  • It’s unclear who’s in charge in Iran. The new Supreme Leader was reportedly badly injured and hasn’t appeared in public since he took power in March. Iran’s top security official is now demanding that the United States “surrender” to Iran’s conditions.
  • Inspectors are starting from scratch. The IAEA has lost track of Iran’s uranium. Before any deal can work, inspectors have to find and account for 440 kilograms of near-weapons-grade material.
  • Iran knows more now. It has mastered faster centrifuges and higher enrichment. A deal can limit what Iran does, but it can’t erase what Iran knows.
  • The world is more divided. In 2015, Russia and China sat at the table with us. Today they opposed the return of UN sanctions, and Gulf countries hit by Iranian missiles want a say in any deal.
  • Fixing the 2015 deal’s weaknesses will take more. A better deal would need to last longer and cover more, and Iran will ask a higher price for that.

Hard isn’t the same as impossible. Ronald Reagan negotiated arms limits with the Soviet Union, a far bigger threat, by insisting on one rule: trust, but verify. That’s the approach we need.

The ideas in detail

1. Let Congress decide

The Constitution gives Congress, not the president, the power to declare war. The new Congress should hold a clear vote on this war in its first weeks. We believe that vote should set a deadline to wind down offensive operations while keeping the authority to defend our troops, our ships, and our allies from attack. That holds no matter which party is in the White House.

2. Get to a ceasefire and reopen the Strait

  • Back the mediators, including Qatar and Oman, who are already carrying messages between Washington and Tehran.
  • Make reopening the Strait of Hormuz the first step, with an international naval mission to protect shipping.
  • Coordinate with Israel and our Gulf partners, so a ceasefire protects them too.

3. Build a new deal that verifies everything

A new agreement should, at a minimum:

  • Put inspectors back in every site, including those damaged in the strikes, with short-notice access.
  • Account for every kilogram of the 60% uranium and ship it out of the country or blend it down.
  • Keep enrichment far below weapons grade, or end it, with limits that don’t simply expire.
  • Lift sanctions in steps, only as inspectors confirm Iran has met each one.
  • Bring sanctions back automatically if Iran cheats.

4. Make it last: a treaty, not a handshake

The 2015 deal’s biggest weakness was here at home. It passed with the support of only one party and never got a Senate vote as a treaty, so it was easy to undo. The next deal should go to the Senate for ratification, with the two-thirds vote the Constitution requires. That means building support in both parties from the start, the way Arthur Vandenberg and Harry Truman did after World War II. A deal Republicans and Democrats both own is a deal Iran can’t wait out.

5. Bring our allies back to the table

Britain, France, and Germany negotiated the 2015 deal with us and asked us to stay in it. Any new deal should be built with them, with the European Union, and with our Gulf partners. Allies make sanctions stronger, inspections more credible, and a deal harder to break.

6. Deal with missiles and militias too

The 2015 deal left out Iran’s missiles and its support for armed groups across the region. Those threats need their own agreements, built alongside our Gulf partners and Israel. Until then, we should keep targeted sanctions on the Revolutionary Guard and the networks that fund terrorism.

7. Take care of things at home

  • Bring our troops home as the fighting ends.
  • Rebuild our munitions stockpiles with multi-year contracts, including with the Utah companies that already build for our military.
  • Refill the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and protect families from the next price shock, as laid out in our cost of living ideas.
  • Put war costs in the regular budget, paid for honestly instead of quietly borrowed.

8. Stand with the Iranian people

Iran’s government is the main enemy of its own people. In January it violently crushed nationwide protests. We should support Iranians’ access to the internet and outside news, speak up for political prisoners, and welcome those who flee persecution. Lasting change in Iran has to come from Iranians, not from American bombs.

Questions people ask

Isn’t stopping a nuclear Iran worth the cost?

Yes. That’s exactly why this matters. The strikes in 2025 and 2026 have damaged Iran’s program. But the Pentagon’s own target list for the 2026 strikes didn’t include Iran’s nuclear sites, and inspectors can’t see what’s left. Bombing can buy time. Only inspectors on the ground can tell us whether Iran has rebuilt.

Why would we trust Iran?

We shouldn’t. The 2015 deal didn’t depend on trust. It depended on inspectors who checked, every day, that Iran was doing what it promised. Iran did keep the limits until after we left. Any new deal has to be built the same way: verify everything, and bring back sanctions automatically if Iran cheats.

Didn’t the 2015 deal give Iran billions of dollars?

It unfroze Iranian money held in foreign banks. That was Iran’s own money, not American tax dollars. Critics were right to worry that some of it could reach groups like Hezbollah. That’s why a new deal should come with targeted sanctions on the people who fund terrorism.

Isn’t this just partisan?

It shouldn’t be. Keeping a nuclear weapon out of Iran’s hands has been the goal of presidents from both parties. The trouble started when Iran policy became a party fight: one party built a deal alone, and the other undid it alone. We want a deal both parties vote for.

Why should Utah care about a war so far away?

Because Utahns have seen bigger gas price increases than any other state. Because the stockpiles this war has drained are part of our defense, and Utah helps build and maintain them. And because the money spent on this war is borrowed money our kids will pay back.

The bottom line

Iran must never get a nuclear weapon. We had a deal, built with our allies and checked by inspectors, that kept Iran a year away from one. We walked away, Iran raced ahead, and now we’re paying for it in lives, in dollars, and at the pump. The way forward is to let Congress end this war, then build a stronger deal with our allies that both parties sign onto, so it outlasts any one president.

Sources