Main Street First: Making It Easier to Start, Run, and Grow a Business

At a glance

  • 99% of Utah businesses are small, and they employ nearly half of Utah’s workers.
  • Cut the costs only big companies can bargain down: credit card swipe fees, health insurance, and tariffs.
  • Less paperwork, not less protection: one set of rules sized for a 10-person shop, not a 10,000-person company.
  • Keep small business taxes low and simple, and make it easier to borrow, hire, and find child care.

11 min read

What we want to accomplish

Make Utah the easiest place in America to start a business, keep it open, and grow it.

  1. Lower the costs that only big companies can bargain down. Credit card swipe fees, health insurance, and tariffs hit small businesses hardest.
  2. Cut paperwork, not protections. Rules should fit the size of the business they’re written for.
  3. Keep small business taxes low, simple, and predictable.
  4. Make it easier to borrow, especially the small loans that get a business started or through a slow season.
  5. Help small businesses find and keep good workers, through guest worker visas, skills training, and help with child care.

What we shouldn’t do

  • Raise taxes on small businesses earning under $400,000 a year.
  • Write rules for Fortune 500 companies and expect a family shop to follow them the same way.
  • Raise the cost of what small businesses buy with broad tariffs on imported parts, equipment, and supplies.
  • Pick winners by handing special breaks to big, well-connected companies that the corner store can’t get.

Why this matters

When people talk about “the economy,” they often picture big companies. In Utah, the economy is mostly small businesses. According to the Small Business Administration’s latest count, 371,569 small businesses operate here, 99.4% of all businesses in the state. They employ nearly half of Utah’s private workforce. They’re the restaurant in Cedar City, the HVAC company in Ogden, the family farm in Sanpete County, and the software startup in Lehi.

Utahns start businesses at one of the fastest rates in the country. Over the past year, Utah had more than 83,000 new business applications, up nearly 28% from the year before, and one of the highest rates per person of any state.

Utah keeps adding small businessesNumber of small businesses in Utah, by edition of the SBA's state profile2017: 268,872269K20172019: 287,803288K20192020: 301,265301K20202021: 313,590314K20212024: 352,191352K20242025: 371,569372K2025
Small businesses are firms with fewer than 500 employees, including the self-employed. Each SBA profile edition uses the latest Census data available at the time, usually two to three years earlier. Source: SBA Office of Advocacy, Utah Small Business Profiles.

That’s something to be proud of. But starting a business is the easy part. Keeping it open is harder, and too often Washington makes it harder still.

What small business owners say

Every month, the National Federation of Independent Business asks owners to name their single biggest problem. In October 2026, the top answer was finding qualified workers, followed by taxes, which jumped to its highest level since 2021, and then inflation.

What small business owners say is their biggest problemShare of owners naming each as their single most important problem, October 2026Finding qualified workersFinding qualified workers: 25%25%TaxesTaxes: 21%21%InflationInflation: 17%17%Cost of laborCost of labor: 7%7%Government regulationGovernment regulation: 7%7%Cost of insuranceCost of insurance: 7%7%Poor salesPoor sales: 6%6%Competition from big businessCompetition from big business: 5%5%Financing & interest ratesFinancing & interest rates: 3%3%
Source: NFIB, Small Business Economic Trends, October 2026 (national survey of NFIB members).

Underneath those answers is a simple problem: small businesses pay more for almost everything. A big company can negotiate its credit card fees, spread its health insurance risk over thousands of workers, and hire a team to handle compliance. A business with eight employees can’t. The rules are often the same, but the cost per worker is not.

The costs that fall hardest on small businesses

Credit card swipe fees

Every time a customer pays with a card, the business pays a fee, usually 2% to 4% of the sale. For many small businesses, it’s now one of their biggest costs after payroll. That’s not because the market sets it. Two networks, Visa and Mastercard, control about 80% of card processing, and stores can’t shop around.

This is one of the rare issues where both parties agree. The bipartisan Credit Card Competition Act, from Republican Sen. Roger Marshall and Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin, would require the biggest banks to let stores choose between at least two networks to process a card. President Trump has endorsed it. Small business groups support it. Congress should pass it.

Health insurance

Family coverage through an employer now costs an average of nearly $27,000 a year. Large employers can absorb that and spread the risk. Small employers often can’t, so many don’t offer coverage at all. Their workers end up buying their own insurance, which is one reason about 400,000 Utahns shop on the federal marketplace, one of the highest rates in the country.

Tariffs

Most small businesses don’t import directly, but almost all of them buy things that were imported: parts, equipment, packaging, inventory. When tariffs go up, so do their costs. In a Federal Reserve survey of more than 6,500 small businesses, 42% said tariffs had raised their costs over the past year.

Paperwork

Federal rules cost every business time and money, and the smallest firms usually pay the most per worker because they can’t spread the cost. Researchers don’t agree on exactly how big the gap is, and some find that mid-sized firms carry the heaviest load. But anyone who has run a small business knows the feeling of spending a Saturday on forms instead of customers.

Washington sometimes gets this right. This summer, the Treasury permanently ended a requirement that would have made more than 32 million small businesses file ownership reports with the federal government. That rule was meant to catch money launderers using shell companies. The goal was right, but asking every family LLC to file was the wrong way to get there.

What Utah can teach Washington

In 2021, Utah created the nation’s first general regulatory sandbox. It lets a business with a new idea ask the state to waive a rule for a limited time, under supervision, to show whether the idea is safe and works. If it does, the rule can be changed for everyone. One towing company used it to complete more than 3,700 tows and cut response times in half in some areas, and the results led to a change in state law.

That’s the right approach. Keep rules that protect people, test whether the others are needed, and let small businesses show a better way.

The ideas in detail

1. Cut the costs only big companies can bargain down

  • Pass the Credit Card Competition Act, so stores can choose how their card payments are processed and swipe fees come down through competition.
  • Let small businesses buy into Medicare for their workers. The Medicare buy-in would let a small business offer the plan instead of shopping for a new private plan every year.
  • Restore the marketplace tax credits that kept premiums affordable for the self-employed and workers at small businesses, as laid out in health care costs.
  • End broad tariffs on what small businesses buy, and give Congress back the final say, as laid out in Free Trade, Fair Rules, and No Hidden Taxes.

2. Cut paperwork, not protections

  • Size the rules to the business. Every major new federal rule should come with a simpler version for small businesses, written in plain English, with a single page that explains what’s required.
  • Ask once. If a business has already given information to one federal agency, another agency shouldn’t make it file the same thing again.
  • Fix first, fine later. A small business that makes an honest first-time paperwork mistake should get a warning and a chance to fix it before it gets a fine. That doesn’t apply to rules that protect health and safety.
  • Build a federal regulatory sandbox modeled on Utah’s, so businesses can test new ideas under supervision and show which federal rules need updating.

3. Keep small business taxes low, simple, and predictable

The 2025 tax law made the 20% small business deduction permanent, along with the full write-off for equipment. Small businesses can plan around both, and we should keep them. The tax ideas on this site would also:

  • Raise the deduction for starting a business from $5,000 to $20,000, so someone opening a shop or a landscaping company can write off more of their first-year costs.
  • Keep the 20% deduction for everyone under $1 million in business income, which covers the vast majority of small businesses.
  • Make every special tax break prove itself, so well-connected industries don’t get breaks the corner store can’t.

4. Make it easier to borrow

The Small Business Administration guarantees loans that private lenders might not make on their own. In fiscal 2026, its main loan program made 56,130 loans, a double-digit drop from the year before, as the agency tightened its rules and raised fees. Some of that tightening made sense, since defaults were rising. But the drop has hit hardest on smaller loans, the kind a new business or a family shop is most likely to need.

  • Bring back a simple, fast track for loans under $150,000, with sensible safeguards, so lenders can afford to make them.
  • Support Utah’s community banks and credit unions, which know local businesses and make many of their loans.
  • Require clear, honest pricing on all small business financing, including merchant cash advances, so an owner can compare the true cost the way consumers can with a car loan.

5. Help small businesses find and keep good workers

  • Year-round guest worker visas that follow the job market. Today’s legal options barely fit the jobs where Utah is shortest of workers. Farm visas only cover seasonal agriculture, the visa for other seasonal jobs is capped at 66,000 a year nationwide, and there’s essentially no visa for year-round work like construction, dairies, or elder care. We should create one that rises and falls with demand, with prevailing wages and full payroll taxes so American workers aren’t undercut. It should be simple enough that a 10-person business can use it without hiring a lawyer. The details are in the immigration ideas.
  • Make child care help easy for small employers to use. Utah’s child care shortage costs the state an estimated $1.3 billion a year in wages and productivity. Federal and Utah tax credits together now cover up to 80% of child care costs a small business pays for its workers. That’s a good start, but few small businesses use them. Washington should let small employers pool together to buy child care slots, and make the federal credit simple enough to claim without an accountant.
  • Train Utahns for the skilled jobs. Guest workers can’t fill every opening. Electricians, mechanics, nurses, and truck drivers need training and licenses. We should expand technical college programs and apprenticeships built with the businesses that are hiring, and make it easy for licensed workers from other states to work in Utah.

Questions people ask

Don’t other ideas on this site raise taxes on small businesses?

A few ask more of the highest earners, and we want to be upfront about who that is. The Medicaid ideas apply the 3.8% Medicare tax to business income over $400,000, the same tax high earners already pay on their wages. The tax ideas cap the 20% deduction at $1 million of business income. The vast majority of small businesses earn far less than either line and see no change, except a bigger deduction for starting up.

Isn’t small business mostly a Republican issue?

It shouldn’t belong to either party. The best idea on this page, letting stores choose their card network, is sponsored by a Republican and a Democrat and endorsed by President Trump. Main Street doesn’t care which party fixes the problem.

Why not just cut all regulations?

Some rules protect people: food safety, workplace safety, clean water, honest advertising. Small business owners want those rules too, because a bad actor hurts everyone’s reputation. The goal is rules that fit the business they’re written for, and that get tested and updated instead of piling up forever.

The bottom line

Small businesses are how most Utahns get their first job, and how many of them build something of their own. They don’t need special favors. They need Washington to stop writing rules as if every business has a legal department, to let them compete on fair terms with the biggest companies, and to get out of the way when they’re ready to grow.

Sources