A Real Friend to Israel
At a glance
- Israel’s right to exist and defend itself is not up for debate, and Hamas must never govern Gaza again.
- The suffering in Gaza is a tragedy. More than 74,000 Palestinians have died, and the ceasefire has not ended the hunger.
- Two states are the only path to lasting peace. That means no more settlement expansion or annexation in the West Bank.
- Wind down U.S. aid in an orderly way, as Israel’s own leaders have proposed, and apply our laws the same way to every country we arm.
Where we stand
Israel is a democracy and a friend. On October 7, 2023, Hamas killed about 1,200 people and took 251 hostages in the deadliest day for Jewish people since the Holocaust. Israel had every right to respond, and Hamas must never rule Gaza again.
But a real friend tells hard truths. The war that followed has killed tens of thousands of Palestinians, many of them women and children, and left Gaza in ruins. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has lost the trust of most of his own people, pushed for a war with Iran that pulled our country in, and expanded settlements that make peace harder.
Most Americans, of every faith and both parties, want the same things: a safe Israel, an end to the killing in Gaza, a future where Palestinians can live in a state of their own, and Jewish Americans who feel safe at home. We think all of that can be true at once.
What we want to accomplish
- A secure Israel, protected from Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iran.
- An end to the suffering in Gaza, with Hamas disarmed and out of power and aid flowing freely.
- Two states for two peoples, living side by side in peace.
- An orderly end to U.S. military aid, replaced by a partnership between equals.
- The same rules for everyone on how American weapons are used.
- Israel as a cause that unites Americans, not one more wedge between the parties.
- A country where Jewish Americans, and Americans of every faith, are safe.
What we shouldn’t do
- Question Israel’s right to exist or treat criticism of a government as hatred of a people.
- Treat criticism of Netanyahu as antisemitism. Most Israelis disagree with him too.
- Write blank checks to any foreign government, or let any ally pull us into a war Congress never approved.
- Ignore the suffering of Palestinian civilians or excuse Hamas’s crimes.
- Accept settlement expansion and annexation that close the door on two states.
- Use Israel or Jewish Americans as a political weapon against the other party.
The tragedy in Gaza
The October 7 attack started this war. Hamas murdered families in their homes and at a music festival and dragged hundreds into Gaza. The last hostage, police officer Ran Gvili, who was killed defending a kibbutz that morning, was finally brought home in January 2026, after 843 days.
The war that followed has been devastating for Gaza’s people. Gaza’s Health Ministry, part of the Hamas-run government, says more than 74,000 Palestinians have been killed and more than 175,000 wounded. A U.S.-brokered ceasefire took effect in October 2025, but the dying hasn’t stopped. More than 1,400 people have been killed in Gaza since the ceasefire began. The UN expects 1.4 million people, two-thirds of Gaza, to face crisis-level hunger or worse in the second half of 2026. More than 43,000 people have injuries that may change their lives forever.
The next stage of the ceasefire has stalled. Hamas still hasn’t disarmed. Israeli troops haven’t withdrawn. The international security force meant to keep the peace is still forming, and rebuilding has barely begun.
Hamas bears the blame for starting this war and for hiding among civilians. Israel’s government bears responsibility for how it has fought it and for the limits it has placed on aid. Both things are true, and a serious policy has to hold both in mind.
Netanyahu doesn’t speak for most Israelis
Many Americans assume Netanyahu is broadly popular at home. He isn’t.
| What Israelis say | The numbers |
|---|---|
| Distrust Netanyahu (JPPI, June 2026) | 6 in 10 |
| Wanted a new prime minister after the election (Channel 12) | 58%, vs. 32% for another Netanyahu term |
| Knesset members who backed his rival to form the next government | 67, vs. 46 for Netanyahu |
His party, Likud, still won the most seats in the October 27 election, and he kept strong support among his base. But no bloc won a majority, and Israel’s president asked Gadi Eisenkot, a former army chief, to try to form the next government first. Netanyahu stays on as caretaker prime minister while talks continue.
Supporting Israel doesn’t mean supporting whoever leads it, any more than supporting America means agreeing with every president.
How Netanyahu helped pull us into war with Iran
Netanyahu has called for a war on Iran for decades. Reuters reported that two days before the strikes began, he made the case to President Trump on the phone, arguing there might never be a better chance to kill Iran’s Supreme Leader. An American official told Axios the original plan called for strikes in late March or April, to give the administration time to build public support, and that Netanyahu pushed to move faster. As of November, AP reports that he is pressing for new strikes on Iran.
Some Israeli officials dispute that Netanyahu “dragged” America into the war, and Reuters noted he didn’t force the decision. That’s the point. Our country’s decisions about war are ours to make, and they belong to Congress. A friend can make its case. It can’t make the choice for us. As we explain in No Nuclear Iran, No Endless War, that war has cost American lives, billions of dollars, and record gas prices here in Utah.
Aid to Israel: time for Israel to carry its own bill
Since 2019, the United States has given Israel $3.8 billion a year in military aid under a 10-year agreement signed in 2016. It runs through 2028. Most of it must be spent with American defense companies.
Israel is a wealthy country with a strong economy, a growing arms industry, and universal health care for its citizens. It can pay for its own defense. Israel’s own leaders agree. Netanyahu has said he wants U.S. aid to start coming down now and keep going down to zero, because Israel has “come of age.” President Trump said in November that U.S. aid packages would end by the end of 2026.
We agree with the goal. The way to get there matters. A sudden cutoff in the middle of a regional war would be reckless. An orderly phase-out, with joint work on missile defense like Iron Dome continuing, protects Israel and saves American taxpayers money.
The same rules for every country
Ending aid doesn’t end American responsibility. Israel will keep buying American weapons, and our laws apply to every sale. The Leahy Law bars U.S. help for military units credibly linked to gross human rights abuses. The Arms Export Control Act limits how American weapons may be used. These laws aren’t aimed at Israel. They apply to every country we arm, and they should be enforced the same way under every president.
That’s not a radical idea. In April 2026, 40 of 47 Senate Democrats voted to block a sale of military bulldozers to Israel, while every Republican voted to allow it. We don’t think every sale should become a party-line fight. Clear rules, applied the same way to every country, would take the politics out of it.
Two states, and no annexation
A two-state solution, with a secure Israel next to a peaceful Palestinian state, is the one approach that lets Israel stay both Jewish and democratic and gives Palestinians a future. Most Americans agree: 57% support a Palestinian state alongside Israel, near the highest Gallup has ever measured. Fewer Israelis and Palestinians agree today, after years of terror and war. That’s why American leadership matters.
The biggest obstacle on the ground is the steady expansion of settlements in the West Bank. Israel’s government approved a record number of new settlements in 2025, and it has moved ahead with the E1 project east of Jerusalem, which would split the West Bank in two. Settler violence against Palestinians has risen as well. Annexation, formal or creeping, would end any hope of two states. American policy should oppose it clearly.
Supporting Israel abroad and Jewish Americans at home
A popular talking point says one party supports Jewish Americans and the other doesn’t. The record is more complicated, and both parties can claim real support.
- Democrats elect Jewish leaders in large numbers. In January, all 10 Jewish U.S. senators will be Democrats or caucus with them, and 25 of the 28 Jewish members elected to the House this month are Democrats. About two in three Jewish voters backed Democrats in the 2026 midterms.
- Republicans have been the most reliable votes for Israel’s military. Every Senate Republican voted against blocking arms sales to Israel this year.
The divide that’s growing isn’t about whether Americans care about Jewish people. It’s about this Israeli government’s wars. Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, one of the country’s most prominent Jewish leaders, put it well on Pod Save America. He said it’s “fair game to criticize the Netanyahu government,” and that disagreeing with that government doesn’t make someone an antisemite. We need “two distinct conversations,” he said: one about Israel’s policies, and one about calling out antisemitism wherever it shows up, “on the political left or the political right.” He has also said Netanyahu fractured what used to be bipartisan American support for Israel.
We agree. You can challenge Israel’s government and stand with Jewish Americans at home. The two aren’t in conflict. Antisemitism is real and rising, and it must be confronted wherever it shows up. So must hatred of Muslims and Arab Americans. Israel’s security used to unite Americans. Politics should stop at the water’s edge here too.
The ideas in detail
1. Help finish the job in Gaza
- Back the ceasefire’s next stage: Hamas disarmed, Israeli forces pulling back as an international force takes over security, and a Palestinian government without Hamas.
- Flood Gaza with aid, with every crossing open and aid workers protected.
- Lead an international effort to rebuild, paid for mostly by Gulf states and Europe, with strict controls so Hamas can’t rebuild its tunnels.
2. Keep Israel safe from Iran and its proxies
Keep sharing intelligence and building missile defense together. Stopping Iran from getting a nuclear weapon protects Israel too, through a verified deal, as laid out in our Iran ideas.
3. Phase out military aid in an orderly way
- Write the next agreement as a step-down to zero on a clear schedule, as Israel’s own leaders have proposed.
- Keep joint projects that help both countries, like missile defense research.
- Move from aid to trade, with Israel buying what it needs from American companies.
4. Apply the same rules to everyone
Enforce the Leahy Law and the Arms Export Control Act for every country that buys or receives American weapons. Report to Congress on how those weapons are used. Make the rules predictable, so arms sales stop being a partisan fight.
5. Keep two states possible
- Oppose new settlements and annexation in the West Bank, and say so clearly.
- Hold violent settlers accountable, including with sanctions on those who attack Palestinians.
- Work with Arab partners on a path to a Palestinian state that recognizes Israel and rejects terror, with normal ties between Israel and its neighbors.
6. Fight hate at home
Fund security for synagogues, churches, mosques, and schools. Enforce civil rights laws against antisemitism and anti-Muslim hate on campuses and in workplaces. And keep our debates about Israel’s government free of attacks on Jewish Americans.
Questions people ask
Is criticizing Netanyahu antisemitic?
No. Most Israelis distrust him, and many of his strongest critics are Israeli and Jewish. Criticizing a government’s policies is what democracies do. Attacking Jewish people, or blaming them for what Israel’s government does, is antisemitism.
Why end aid if Israel is our friend?
Because Israel is strong enough to stand on its own, and its own leaders want to. Friends who are equals buy and sell, build together, and defend each other. They don’t need a check every year.
Doesn’t a two-state solution reward Hamas?
No. Hamas rejects two states because it rejects Israel. A Palestinian state led by people who recognize Israel and reject terror is Hamas’s worst defeat.
Why does this matter in Utah?
Utahns care deeply about the Holy Land. Many have visited or studied there, including at BYU’s Jerusalem Center, and Utah is home to Jewish, Christian, and Muslim communities who all want peace. And when a war in the region pulls America in, Utahns pay at the pump.
The bottom line
A real friend to Israel wants it safe, democratic, and at peace. That means standing against Hamas and Iran, ending the suffering in Gaza, opposing annexation, and keeping a two-state future possible. It means asking a wealthy ally to carry its own defense bill and applying our laws the same way to every country we arm. It also means remembering that support for Israel used to unite Americans, and can again.
Sources
- Al-Monitor / Reuters: Israel’s first election since October 7
- AJC: the last hostage, Ran Gvili, recovered after 843 days
- Boston Globe / AP: Gaza death toll passes 74,000
- Korea Times / Reuters: one year on, the Gaza plan has not stopped the fire or disarmed Hamas
- UN OCHA: Gaza reported impact snapshot (November 2026)
- JPPI Israeli Society Index (June 2026)
- Yeshiva World / Channel 12: most Israelis want a new prime minister
- JNS: final results of Israel’s October 27 election
- Al Jazeera: Herzog picks Eisenkot to form the next government
- Saudi Gazette / AA: Netanyahu remains caretaker prime minister
- GV Wire / Reuters: Trump approved the Iran operation after Netanyahu’s call
- Axios: the Trump-Netanyahu call that changed the Middle East
- Anchorage Daily News / AP: Netanyahu pressing Trump to attack Iran after the midterms
- Israel Hayom: who really dragged whom into the war with Iran?
- Dawn: Israel plans to end dependence on U.S. military aid
- Jewish Insider: Netanyahu wants to start winding down U.S. aid now
- Jerusalem Post: phasing out Israel’s local purchasing of U.S. aid
- Newsweek: Trump announces end to aid packages for Israel
- Ynet: Israel’s 2026 defense budget raised to 144 billion shekels
- Israel Policy Forum: U.S. security assistance and the Israeli budget
- Times of Israel: record 85% of Senate Democrats back blocking an arms sale (April 2026)
- Gallup: Israelis no longer ahead in Americans’ Middle East sympathies (February 2026)
- Anadolu: Gallup finds 57% support a Palestinian state
- Peace Now: key settlement data for 2025
- EU Office: 2025 report on Israeli settlements in the West Bank
- Chatham House: Israel’s accelerating de facto annexation of the West Bank
- Jewish Journal: Jewish winners in the 2026 elections
- J. Weekly: did Republicans gain Jewish votes in the 2026 midterms?
- Times of Israel: Jewish voters in both parties worry about antisemitism
- Washington Free Beacon: Shapiro on Netanyahu and bipartisan support for Israel (October 2026)
- Pod Save America: “Josh Shapiro Is Calm but Not Cool” (March 15, 2026)
- The Hill via AOL: Shapiro leans into support for Israel on podcast tour