Great Public Schools Start With Teachers

At a glance

  • Utah spends the 2nd-least per student and has the most crowded classes in the country, yet our kids still beat the national average.
  • Smaller classes, a real push to keep new teachers, and a counselor or psychologist on site in every school.
  • Washington should keep its special education promise, and public money should go to public schools first.
  • Better than average isn’t the goal. The best in the country is.

14 min read

Where we stand

We should do everything we can to support Utah’s public schools. Most Utah kids sit in a public classroom, and those classrooms belong to all of us. Utah teachers get strong results with less money per student than almost any state and some of the largest classes in the country. They’ve earned support, not more paperwork. And beating the national average isn’t the finish line. We expect the best for our kids, so Utah’s schools should aim to be the best in the country.

Washington shouldn’t run Utah’s schools. Local school boards, parents, and the state should. But Washington should keep the promises it has already made to them, and it should get out of teachers’ way.

What we want to accomplish

  1. Aim for the best, not just above average. Utah should set the goal of leading the nation in reading and math, not just beating the average. Why: we expect the best for our kids, and they’re capable of it.
  2. Smaller classes. We should bring class sizes down, starting in the early grades where it makes the biggest difference. Why: Utah has more students per teacher than any other state, and a teacher with 30 kids can’t give each one the time they need.
  3. Keep new teachers in the classroom. We should pay for mentors in a new teacher’s first years and raise pay in the middle of a career, not just at the start. Why: Utah keeps veteran teachers well, but about 4 in 10 new teachers leave within five years.
  4. Real help for every kind of learner. Every school should have counselors, school psychologists, social workers, and nurses on site, with the time and training to support students with anxiety, depression, ADHD, autism, and other needs. Why: one in seven Utah students has a disability, and Utah’s support staff carry two to ten times the caseloads experts recommend.
  5. Keep Washington’s promise on special education. Congress pledged in 1975 to pay 40% of the extra cost of special education. It pays a fraction of that today. Congress should close that gap on a schedule. Why: every dollar Washington shorts special education comes out of everyone else’s classroom.
  6. Respect teachers’ time. We should cut federal paperwork and reporting that doesn’t help a student learn, and let teachers have a real say in the decisions that affect their classrooms. Why: teachers who leave say the workload and the lack of respect wore them down more than the paycheck.
  7. Public money for public schools first. We should fully fund the schools that serve most Utah kids before expanding programs that send public dollars elsewhere, and never tie teacher pay to a voucher program.

What we shouldn’t do

  • Let Washington set curriculum. What Utah kids learn is for Utah parents, teachers, and school boards to decide.
  • Treat teachers as the problem. Utah’s results show the opposite.
  • Pretend money is the only answer. It isn’t. But Utah has proven how far a dollar can stretch, and it’s stretched about as far as it can go.

The background

Utah does more with less

The state counts Utah among the top two states in education, and it does it on a shoestring. In fiscal 2024, Utah spent $11,347 per student, second-lowest in the nation, while the national average reached $17,619. For more than two decades Utah ranked dead last.

Utah spends less per student than almost anyonePublic school current spending per student, fiscal 2024U.S. averageU.S. average: $17,619$17,619ArizonaArizona: $12,003$12,003UtahUtah: $11,347$11,347IdahoIdaho: $11,060$11,060
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 Annual Survey of School System Finances (May 2026).

Part of that is simple math. Utah has a larger share of school-age kids than any other state, so every school dollar is split more ways. That’s a blessing for Utah, and it’s also why our classrooms are so full.

The state has stepped up. Lawmakers raised the basic per-student funding formula every year from 2023 through 2026, and Gov. Cox and the Legislature pushed starting teacher pay to between $60,000 and $65,000, the highest in the Mountain West. That’s real progress and it deserves credit. But education spending as a share of Utahns’ income has fallen from 5.1% in 2002 to 3.5%, and we’ve slipped from 16th to 40th on that measure. Meanwhile, the Legislature has cut the income tax, the money the Utah Constitution sets aside for schools, six years in a row.

Utah's school effort has slippedPublic education spending as a share of Utahns' personal income2002 (16th in the U.S.)2002 (16th in the U.S.): 5.1%5.1%2022 (40th in the U.S.)2022 (40th in the U.S.): 3.5%3.5%
Source: Salt Lake Tribune, February 2025.
2ndlowest spending per student in the U.S. (2024)
20.3students per teacher in Utah, the most of any state
42%of new Utah teachers left within their first five years

Utah students beat the national average

Those thin budgets still produce strong results. On the 2024 Nation’s Report Card, Utah fourth and eighth graders scored above the national average in both reading and math, with eighth-grade math 10 points ahead. Utah ranked third in the country for fourth-grade math proficiency and fourth for eighth grade, and third for fourth-grade reading.

Utah students score above the national averagePoints above the national average on the 2024 Nation's Report Card (NAEP)8th-grade math8th-grade math: +10+104th-grade reading4th-grade reading: +5+58th-grade reading8th-grade reading: +4+4
Utah vs. national average scale scores: 8th-grade math 282 vs. 272; 4th-grade reading 219 vs. 214; 8th-grade reading 261 vs. 257. Utah also scored significantly above the nation in 4th-grade math. Source: National Center for Education Statistics, via Deseret News.

The gains hold through high school. Utah’s graduation rate reached 89.8% for the class of 2025, up from 85.9% in 2017, while the dropout rate fell by nearly half. Utah also leads the states where most students take the ACT, and its graduates averaged 20.0, above the national average of 19.4.

3rdin the nation for 4th-grade math and reading proficiency (2024)
89.8%of Utah students graduated on time in 2025
20.0average ACT score, vs. 19.4 nationally (2025)

There are warning signs, too. Utah’s eighth-grade reading score dropped four points from 2022, and fewer than a third of eighth graders are now proficient readers. Utah students are still more than half a grade level behind 2019 in reading. Teachers are holding the line with the largest classes in the country. That can’t last forever.

Better than average isn’t the goal

It’s easy to look at Utah’s scores and call it good enough. We shouldn’t. Being ahead of the national average when the national average is falling isn’t the standard Utah families hold themselves to. Massachusetts still beats Utah in fourth-grade reading and math, and about two-thirds of Utah eighth graders aren’t proficient readers. We expect the best from our kids at home, in church, on the field, and in the classroom. Our schools should expect it of themselves too, and we should give them what they need to get there.

Classes are the largest in the country

Utah has the most students per teacher of any state, well above the national average of about 15. The State Board of Education put the statewide ratio at 20.3 students per teacher in 2025, and actual classes run bigger, often near 30 in secondary science, English, and math. Smaller classes help most in kindergarten through third grade, where kids learn to read and where falling behind is hardest to fix later.

Here’s what that means in a real building. A school of 600 students staffed at Utah’s ratio has about 30 teachers. At the national average of about 15 students per teacher, the same school would have about 40.

Ten fewer teachers in the same schoolTeachers in a 600-student school at each student-teacher ratioAt Utah's ratio (20.3)At Utah's ratio (20.3): 30 teachers30 teachersAt the U.S. average (15.1)At the U.S. average (15.1): 40 teachers40 teachers
Utah ratio: Utah State Board of Education, FY2025. U.S. ratio: NEA, 2024-25. Teacher counts rounded.

The problem is keeping new teachers

Utah is good at keeping teachers once they’ve settled in. The trouble is the first few years. A 2021 legislative audit found that 42% of teachers who started in 2016 had left within five years, higher than most national estimates. Each one who leaves takes years of training with them, and a school has to start over.

When Utah teachers leave, the state’s exit surveys point to burnout, unrealistic workloads, too little prep time, and a lack of respect. A starting salary gets a teacher in the door. Mentoring, manageable workloads, and pay that keeps rising are what keep them there.

Pay tells the same story. Utah now ranks in the top five for starting pay, well above the national average. But the raises flatten out. Utah’s average teacher salary was about $67,600 in 2024, around the middle of the pack and below the national average of $72,030. We pay well to get teachers in the door, then fall behind once they’re experienced enough to be most valuable.

Utah pays well to start, then falls behindUtah teacher pay compared with the national averageStarting pay: UtahStarting pay: Utah: $57,849$57,849Starting pay: U.S.Starting pay: U.S.: $48,112$48,112Average pay: UtahAverage pay: Utah: $67,600$67,600Average pay: U.S.Average pay: U.S.: $72,030$72,030
Starting pay: NEA, 2024-25. Average pay: Utah Governor's Office of Planning and Budget estimate for FY2024 vs. NEA national average for 2023-24.

Help for every kind of learner

A lot of what helps a child succeed happens outside the lesson plan. Some kids are dealing with anxiety or depression. Some have ADHD, autism, or a learning disability and need a different approach to thrive. Today, about 90,000 Utah public school students have a disability, roughly one in seven, up from about one in nine a decade ago. Autism alone now affects about one in 37 Utah eight-year-olds.

More Utah students need extra helpShare of Utah public school students with a disability2013-142013-14: 11%11%2025-26 (about 90,000 students)2025-26 (about 90,000 students): 14%14%
Source: Utah State Board of Education fall enrollment, via Utah Policy.

Those kids do best when help is right there in the building: a counselor who knows them by name, a school psychologist who can evaluate a student this month instead of next year, a social worker who can connect a family to care. Too often that help isn’t there. In 2023, the Legislature itself recorded the shortage: about one counselor for every 500 students, one school psychologist for every 2,100, and one social worker for every 2,400. About half of Utah’s schools don’t have a full-time psychologist, and schools pay psychologists nearly 20% less than they could earn elsewhere in Utah.

Utah's school support staff are stretched thinStudents per staff member in Utah, compared with the recommended caseloadCounselors: UtahCounselors: Utah: 503503Counselors: recommendedCounselors: recommended: 250250Psychologists: UtahPsychologists: Utah: 2,1142,114Psychologists: recommendedPsychologists: recommended: 500500Social workers: UtahSocial workers: Utah: 2,4432,443Social workers: recommendedSocial workers: recommended: 250250
2021-22 school year. Recommended ratios from national professional associations. Source: Utah Legislature, HCR 6 (2023).

When that help is missing, teachers fill the gap, and the other 29 kids in the room wait. That’s part of why new teachers burn out. Utah has done good work here, including the SafeUT crisis app that every student can use around the clock. But an app can’t replace a trained adult down the hall. We should help schools hire and keep more counselors, psychologists, and social workers, and help pay to train them, so that every school has someone on site for the kids who need it.

Washington’s broken promise on special education

When Congress passed the special education law in 1975, it promised to cover 40% of the extra cost of educating students with disabilities. It never has. Today the federal share is roughly 10 to 13%. Schools still have to provide every service the law requires, so the difference comes out of everyone else’s classroom budget. There’s a bipartisan bill to phase in full funding over ten years. I support it.

Vouchers and public schools

Utah’s Fits All scholarship gives families up to $8,000 per student for private school or homeschooling. A district judge ruled it unconstitutional in April 2025, and the program keeps running while the Utah Supreme Court reviews the case. That’s the right place for the legal question to be decided, and I’ll respect what the court decides.

Parents want options, and that’s understandable. Utah already offers a lot of them inside public education: charter schools, online schools, open enrollment, and dual-language programs. The priority should be the schools that serve most Utah kids. Before public money goes anywhere else, those schools should have the teachers, the support staff, and the class sizes our kids deserve. And teacher pay should never hang on a voucher program. The 2023 law that created Fits All made part of teachers’ raise depend on the scholarship staying in effect. Teachers shouldn’t be bargaining chips.

Teachers should have a voice

In 2025 the Legislature passed a law barring teachers, firefighters, and police from bargaining as a group. Utahns gathered more than 250,000 signatures to put it on the ballot, and lawmakers repealed it in a December special session by a wide margin. That was the right call. People who spend every day with our kids should have a seat at the table.

The bottom line

Utah’s public schools are one of the best deals in America, and that’s because of the people who work in them. Smaller classes, real help for every kind of learner, and a little more respect would let them do even more. Better than average is a good start. The best in the country is where we’re headed.

Sources