Free to Worship How, Where, or What We May
At a glance
- The founders believed in God but held very different faiths, so they kept God out of the government’s job.
- The Constitution never mentions God, and it bans any religious test for office.
- Latter-day Saints learned the hard way what happens when religious freedom isn’t protected. Today the faith has 17.9 million members.
- Freedom for your faith means freedom for every faith. Congress now looks more like America, and that makes us stronger.
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
— First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, 1791
Where we stand
Religious freedom is America’s first freedom. It comes first in the Bill of Rights for a reason. The people who wrote it had watched governments in Europe and in the colonies force people to pay for churches they didn’t attend, jail preachers who didn’t have a license, and keep people out of office because of how they prayed.
They chose a different path. America would have no official church. Government wouldn’t tell anyone how to worship, and it wouldn’t favor one faith over another. People would be free to worship how, where, or what they may, or not at all.
Utah knows better than almost anywhere what that promise is worth, because the people who settled this state were driven across a continent when it wasn’t kept. I’ll defend that freedom for every Utahn and every American, whatever their faith.
What we want to accomplish
- A government that takes no side between faiths. Not hostile to religion, and not the servant of any one religion.
- Strong protection for the free exercise of faith, for the largest churches and the smallest congregations alike.
- No religious test for public office, written or unwritten.
- Safe houses of worship. No American should be afraid to go to church, synagogue, mosque, temple, or gurdwara.
- The Utah way: protect faith and fairness together. Utah has shown that religious liberty and equal treatment for everyone can be written into the same law.
What we shouldn’t do
- Pick a national religion, officially or in practice. The founders rejected that, and so should we.
- Push faith out of public life. Religious Americans have every right to bring their values to the public square, to vote them, and to run for office.
- Defend religious freedom only for our own faith. A right we protect only for ourselves isn’t a right. It’s a privilege, and privileges can be taken away.
- Attack candidates for their religion. The Constitution bans religious tests for office. Voters should hold the line the Constitution drew.
The founders believed in God, and disagreed about nearly everything else
The founders weren’t a single religious bloc. They believed in God, and they spoke often about Providence. The Declaration of Independence appeals to “Nature’s God” and to a “Creator” who gave us our rights. But beyond that shared belief, their faiths were remarkably different.
Most belonged to a church, usually Anglican (later Episcopal), Congregationalist, or Presbyterian, partly because in several colonies church membership came with public life. Some were devout. John Adams was a lifelong churchgoer who called Christianity the religion of wisdom and virtue. John Jay and John Hancock were deeply committed believers. Charles Carroll of Maryland was the only Catholic to sign the Declaration.
Several of the most famous founders were something else. Historians describe Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, and others as deeply influenced by Deism, the Enlightenment belief in a Creator who is known through reason and nature rather than through any one church’s teachings. Jefferson cut the miracles out of his own copy of the Gospels. Franklin donated to many of Philadelphia’s congregations, including a synagogue, while questioning many of their doctrines. George Washington attended church but rarely took communion and almost always spoke of God in general terms like “Providence” and “the Great Author.” James Madison kept his personal beliefs so private that historians still debate them.
Historians argue about exactly where each one belongs, and religious Americans of every kind can find founders who look like them. That’s the point. They didn’t agree on religion, so they built a government that didn’t need them to.
How the founders saw religion and government
Many founders believed religion was good for the country. Washington said in his Farewell Address that religion and morality were indispensable supports of a free people. But they drew a sharp line between religion and the power of government.
- Madison argued in 1785 that the same authority that could establish Christianity over other faiths could just as easily establish one Christian church over all the others. He led the fight that ended Virginia’s tax for churches.
- Jefferson wrote Virginia’s Statute for Religious Freedom in 1786, which said no one could be forced to support any church or be punished for what they believed. He was proud enough of it to put it on his tombstone.
- Washington wrote to the Jewish congregation in Newport, Rhode Island, in 1790 that the American government gives “to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.”
- The Senate unanimously ratified the Treaty of Tripoli in 1797, signed by President John Adams, which stated that the American government was not founded on the Christian religion. The treaty was written to reassure a Muslim nation that America had no religious quarrel with it.
God is not mentioned in the Constitution
Here’s a fact that surprises many people: the Constitution never mentions God. The only religious phrase is in the date at the end, “in the Year of our Lord,” which was simply how dates were written. Its only rule about religion in the original text is in Article VI: “no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.”
That was a radical choice for 1787. Many states at the time still required officeholders to be Protestant or to swear to Christian beliefs. The founders made the national government different on purpose. Four years later, the First Amendment went further, barring Congress from establishing any religion or interfering with how people practice their faith.
Not everyone liked it. Some ministers at the time called the Constitution “godless,” and several states kept their own official churches for decades. Massachusetts didn’t end its state support for churches until 1833. Some Americans today believe the country was founded as a Christian nation, and it’s true that most early Americans were Christians and that Christian ideas shaped the founders’ thinking. But the government they designed doesn’t belong to any faith. It belongs to all of us.
Utah knows what happens when that promise isn’t kept
The First Amendment didn’t protect the early Latter-day Saints, and their story shows exactly why religious freedom matters.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints was organized in New York in 1830 with six members. Within a decade, its members had been driven from Ohio and then from Missouri. In October 1838, Missouri Governor Lilburn Boggs issued an order declaring that the Saints “must be exterminated or driven from the State.” Days later, a mob killed 17 people at Haun’s Mill. About 10,000 Latter-day Saints were forced out of Missouri in the middle of winter. Missouri didn’t formally rescind the order until 1976.
Joseph Smith went to Washington to ask for help. President Martin Van Buren reportedly told him, “What can I do? I can do nothing for you.” At the time, the Supreme Court had ruled that the Bill of Rights limited only the federal government, not the states. A state could drive out a whole faith, and the First Amendment offered no shelter. In 1844, Joseph Smith was killed by a mob in Carthage, Illinois, and the Saints set out for the Great Basin.
The federal government’s record wasn’t perfect either. In the decades that followed, Congress passed laws aimed at the Church’s practice of plural marriage, the Supreme Court upheld them, and in 1887 Congress moved to seize Church property. People of good faith can debate those laws, but the lesson for every religious minority is the same: a right is only as strong as our willingness to apply it to people we disagree with.
The promise eventually took hold. After the Civil War, the 14th Amendment allowed the courts to apply the First Amendment to the states, and starting in 1940, the Supreme Court did. Under that protection, a faith that was once chased out of state after state has flourished. The Church has grown from about 1.1 million members in 1950 to more than 17.8 million in 2025, with 204 temples worldwide and more than 78,000 full-time missionaries serving in countries that also chose to allow religious freedom.
That growth would have been far harder, maybe impossible, without the freedom the founders wrote down. Joseph Smith put the principle in the Church’s 11th Article of Faith in 1842:
“We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may.”
— Joseph Smith, Articles of Faith, 1842
Note the second half. Allow all men the same privilege. The freedom we claim for ourselves, we owe to everyone else.
Our obligation runs to people of every faith
If religious freedom protects only the majority, it isn’t freedom. The founders wrote it for the dissenters, the minorities, and the newcomers: Baptists in Virginia, Catholics in Protestant colonies, Jews in Newport, and, a generation later, Latter-day Saints on the frontier.
Today the people who need that protection include Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus, Jews, evangelical Christians in secular workplaces, Catholic charities, small congregations fighting zoning boards, and Americans of no faith at all. Attacks on houses of worship, from synagogues in Pittsburgh to Black churches in Charleston to a Sikh temple in Wisconsin, remind us that freedom to worship also means freedom to worship safely.
Utah has shown a better way. In 2015, the Legislature passed what’s become known as the Utah Compromise, backed by the Church, which protected LGBTQ Utahns from discrimination in housing and jobs while also protecting religious freedom. In 2024, Utah passed its own Religious Freedom Restoration Act with unanimous support, and with language making clear it doesn’t undo those protections. Nationally, the Church supported the bipartisan Respect for Marriage Act in 2022 because it included protections for religious organizations. That’s what it looks like when people who disagree work out how to live together.
A Congress that looks more like America
The founders’ promise that there would be no religious test for office is being lived out in a way they might not have imagined.
When the current Congress convened in January 2025, it included 32 Jewish members, nine Latter-day Saints, four Muslims, four Hindus, three Buddhists, and members of many Christian traditions, according to the Pew Research Center. Those numbers are set to grow. In the November 2026 midterms, Michigan voters elected Abdul El-Sayed as the Senate’s first Muslim member, and Arizona sent Dr. Amish Shah to the House as the first member of the Jain faith in Congress.
That makes America stronger, not weaker. A Congress drawn from many faiths reflects the country it serves. It shows the world that America means what it says about freedom. And it reminds every child in a minority faith that the door to public service is open to them too.
This isn’t new. John F. Kennedy, in his 1960 campaign, faced voters who worried a Catholic president would take orders from Rome. In 2007 and again in 2012, Mitt Romney faced voters who weren’t sure about a Latter-day Saint. Both answered the same way: judge me by my record, not my church. That’s the standard the Constitution sets, and it’s the standard we should hold for every candidate.
The ideas in detail
1. Keep government neutral between faiths
- No official or favored religion. Government shouldn’t promote one faith over others, and it shouldn’t treat religious people or groups worse than anyone else.
- Equal access for religious groups. When government offers a benefit, like a grant, a facility, or a program, religious organizations should be able to compete on the same terms as everyone else, as the Supreme Court has held.
2. Protect the free exercise of faith
- Keep the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act strong. Passed in 1993 with near-unanimous bipartisan support, it requires the government to have a compelling reason before burdening someone’s faith.
- Protect small congregations. Enforce the federal law that stops local governments from using zoning to block churches, mosques, synagogues, and temples.
- Respect conscience. People shouldn’t have to choose between their faith and their job when there’s a reasonable way to accommodate both.
3. Keep houses of worship safe
- Fully fund the Nonprofit Security Grant Program, which helps churches, synagogues, mosques, and temples pay for security.
- Prosecute attacks on houses of worship as the hate crimes they are, no matter who the victims are.
4. Faith and fairness together
- Use the Utah model nationally. Protect religious liberty and protect Americans from discrimination in the same law, the way Utah did in 2015 and Congress did in 2022.
5. No religious test, in law or at the ballot box
- Call out religious bigotry in campaigns, no matter which party or which faith is targeted. Questioning someone’s fitness for office because of how they worship goes against the spirit of Article VI.
- Stand up for religious freedom abroad, where people are still jailed and killed for their faith. My foreign policy overview makes it a priority.
The bottom line
The founders believed in God, but they didn’t agree on how to worship, so they built a government that wouldn’t take sides. That decision gave America its first freedom. Utahns, of all people, know what that freedom is worth, because the pioneers who settled this state paid dearly when it wasn’t protected and built something remarkable once it was. Defending religious liberty means defending it for everyone: every faith, every congregation, and every American who chooses none. That’s what makes America strong.
Sources
- National Archives: the Bill of Rights
- National Archives: the Constitution, including Article VI
- National Archives: the Declaration of Independence
- Britannica: The Founding Fathers, Deism, and Christianity, by David L. Holmes
- Wikipedia: history of religion in the United States
- Lehrman Institute: the founders’ faith, with historians Gordon Wood and Thomas Kidd
- Founders Online: James Madison, Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments, 1785
- Library of Virginia: the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, 1786
- Founders Online: George Washington to the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, 1790
- Yale Avalon Project: the Treaty of Tripoli, 1797
- Library of Congress: Jefferson’s letter to the Danbury Baptists, 1802
- First Amendment Encyclopedia: Joseph Smith and the Missouri Extermination Order
- Wikipedia: the life of Joseph Smith, 1838–1839, Haun’s Mill, and the 1976 rescission
- Church Ensign: Joseph Smith’s quest to secure religious freedom for all (2019)
- BYU Religious Studies Center: Joseph Smith goes to Washington, 1839–40
- Joseph Smith Papers: the Bill of Rights and the states in the 1830s and 1840s
- Church News: historical Church membership statistics
- Church News: 2025 statistical report
- Deseret News: membership passed 17.88 million in 2025, with 204 temples
- The Church of Jesus Christ: the Articles of Faith
- Utah Legislature: S.B. 296 (2015), Antidiscrimination and Religious Freedom Amendments
- Utah Legislature: S.B. 150 (2024), Utah’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act
- KSL: Utah passes religious freedom bill unanimously, with language protecting nondiscrimination laws
- Deseret News via Yahoo: ten years of the Utah Compromise and the Respect for Marriage Act
- Pew Research Center: Faith on the Hill, the religious composition of the 119th Congress
- Religion News Service via Word&Way: the religious makeup of the 119th Congress
- NBC Washington: historic firsts of the 2026 midterms, including the first Muslim senator
- Religion News Service: the first Jain American elected to Congress