Utah Elections Are Safe. Let's Keep Them That Way.
At a glance
- Fraud is real, but it’s rare. Even counting every case the conservative Heritage Foundation has ever found, it’s about 0.0002 percent of the votes cast in the last ten years.
- Utah checked its voter rolls. Out of more than 2 million voters, it found just 13 noncitizens who had voted since 2018, not the "hundreds of thousands" Senator Mike Lee has warned about.
- Mail ballots leave a paper trail. Every one is tracked, checked against the voter’s signature and ID, and kept for audits.
- Keep ballots coming to every voter, make ID free for every Utahn, and protect Utah’s law that gives workers paid time off to vote.
Where we stand
Utahns trust their elections, and they have good reason to. Our county clerks are Republicans and Democrats who live in our communities. Our elections have been reviewed by legislative auditors, by the lieutenant governor, and by researchers the Legislature hired. Every one of them came to the same conclusion: there is no evidence of significant fraud in Utah.
Mail voting is a big reason why. Every mail ballot is tracked, checked against the voter’s signature and ID number, and kept on paper so it can be counted again. Utahns love it. In this year’s primary, about 95 percent of votes came in by mail or drop box.
That’s why it’s troubling when leaders who should know better tell Utahns their elections are full of fraud. Senator Mike Lee has spent the last year casting doubt on the system that elected him. The facts don’t back him up, and Utah’s own Republican election officials have said so.
Election security matters. When audits find problems, like voters who died but stayed on the rolls, they should be fixed fast. But fixing real problems is different from scaring people away from a system that works. And Utah shouldn’t adopt rules that keep eligible Utahns from voting in the name of stopping fraud that isn’t happening.
What we want to accomplish
- Tell the truth about fraud. It’s real, it’s rare, and when it happens, we catch it.
- Keep mailing a ballot to every active voter, instead of ending universal mail voting in 2029.
- Keep both checks on every mail ballot, the signature and the ID number.
- Fix the problems audits find, especially keeping voter rolls clean.
- Make voter ID free and easy for every eligible Utahn, so no one is shut out.
- Protect Utah’s paid time off to vote, and make sure workers know they have it.
- Keep Utah in charge of Utah’s elections, and protect voters’ private data.
What we shouldn’t do
- Spread fraud claims that have already been checked and debunked.
- End mail voting for most Utahns, or make every voter sign up again to keep it.
- Pass ID rules that block eligible citizens from voting, especially rural, older, and disabled Utahns.
- Hand the federal government Utahns’ Social Security numbers and other private data without clear answers about how it will be used.
- Pretend the system is perfect. It isn’t, and audits help us make it better.
How rare is voter fraud?
The Heritage Foundation is a conservative think tank. For years it has kept a database of proven election fraud cases from across the country, and it’s the source many people point to when they say fraud is a big problem. As of last year, Heritage said the database had passed 1,600 cases.
That sounds like a lot until you see how many votes Americans cast. Those 1,600 cases go back decades, to the 1980s and earlier. Just in the five federal general elections from 2016 through 2024, Americans cast more than 650 million ballots. Even if every case Heritage has ever found had happened in the last ten years, that’s about 0.0002 percent of those ballots. That’s about two cases for every million votes, and the real share is smaller still, because the 650 million doesn’t count primaries or local elections.
Heritage says its database is only a sample, and that some fraud goes uncaught. That’s fair. But researchers who’ve studied the cases closely found that many of them aren’t even about illegal voting. Some are about officials breaking the rules, or about petitions. Only a handful involve someone pretending to be another voter at the polls, which is the kind of fraud photo ID laws are meant to stop.
The point isn’t that fraud never happens. It does, and people go to prison for it. The point is that it’s rare, it’s usually caught, and it’s nowhere near big enough to change the outcome of a statewide or national election.
What Utah found when it looked
Utah didn’t just take anyone’s word for it. It checked.
The citizenship audit. In 2025, Lieutenant Governor Deidre Henderson, a Republican, ordered a full review of Utah’s voter rolls. Her office checked more than 2 million voters against driver license records and a federal immigration database. It confirmed that 99.72 percent were U.S. citizens.
It found just 13 noncitizens who had voted. Together they cast about 21 ballots across every election from 2018 to 2024, statewide. All 13 have been taken off the rolls, and Utah has closed the gaps in its registration system that let them on.
Noncitizens aren’t allowed to vote, and those ballots shouldn’t have been cast. But 13 voters over seven years is not a stolen election. About 5,000 more voters couldn’t be confirmed either way, including about 2,000 old records from before Utah used driver licenses to check. Many of them have since shown proof of citizenship.
The legislative audit. Utah law requires regular audits of the election system. In September, the Legislature’s own auditors said again that they did not see significant fraud in Utah’s elections. They also found real things to fix, covered below.
The Legislature’s own study. This year, lawmakers paid Utah Valley University’s Herbert Institute to study whether mail voting is less secure than voting in person. The study found no evidence of significant or widespread fraud in Utah, and no sign that fraud goes up when a state switches to mail voting. It counted 51 fraud cases in Utah from 2000 to 2019, and every one of them came from a single 2006 town election in Daggett County.
Why mail voting is safe
Some people assume voting in person must be safer than voting by mail. In Utah, mail voting may actually give us more ways to check.
- You have to be registered. Only citizens can register, and Utah now checks that against state and federal records.
- Every envelope is tracked. Each ballot envelope has a barcode tied to one voter. You can follow your ballot at vote.utah.gov, from the day it’s mailed to the day it’s counted.
- Every ballot is checked twice. Clerks compare the signature on the envelope to the one on file, and starting this year they also check the last four digits of the voter’s ID number. If something doesn’t match, the voter is contacted to fix it. If they don’t, the ballot isn’t counted.
- Your vote stays secret. Once your identity is confirmed, the ballot is separated from the envelope, so no one can tie your choices to you.
- There’s a paper record. Every ballot is kept, so counts can be checked and audited.
- Firm deadlines. Ballots must be in a drop box or the clerk’s office by 8 p.m. on Election Day.
- One person, one vote. Clerks record who has voted, so a second ballot from the same voter gets flagged.
Utah has also gotten stricter in the last two years, with ID numbers on mail ballots, an earlier return deadline, and a full citizenship check. These are the kinds of reasonable steps that make a good system better.
What Senator Lee has said, and what the facts show
I don’t take this lightly. Senator Lee is Utah’s senior senator, and I’d rather talk about ideas than people. But when a Utah senator repeatedly tells people their elections can’t be trusted, Utahns deserve to hear what the record shows.
He has pushed to end mail voting. In August 2025, when President Trump vowed to get rid of mail ballots, Senator Lee joined in and said people should vote at the polls on Election Day, with exceptions for people like overseas troops. This summer he wrote that mail voting, except for the military and people who can’t get to the polls, “should not survive much longer.” That would end the way about 95 percent of Utahns vote.
He suggested mail carriers could rig elections. Last year he argued that because postal unions endorse candidates, mail voting has conflicts of interest that put the whole system at risk. He gave no examples of postal workers tampering with ballots. Federal law already bars postal workers from partisan activity on the job, and Utah tracks every ballot envelope.
He claimed “hundreds of thousands” of noncitizens are on our rolls. Defending his SAVE America Act, he pointed to hundreds of thousands of noncitizens on America’s voter rolls. When Utah actually checked more than 2 million voters, it found just 13 noncitizens who had voted.
Utah Republicans have pushed back. Lieutenant Governor Henderson has defended Utah’s mail voting and said the state’s elections are secure. Senator John Curtis has said restrictions on mail voting would go against the way Utah does things. The Legislature’s own auditors and researchers found no significant fraud.
Senator Lee has said the acceptable number of illegal votes is zero, and I agree. Every illegal vote should be caught and prosecuted. But the way to get to zero is to keep the checks that are working and fix the gaps audits find. Telling people the system is full of fraud doesn’t do that. It just makes people trust it less.
Fix what audits find
Being honest about elections means admitting where they fall short. Utah’s audits have found real problems:
- People who have died staying on the rolls. A 2024 audit found about 1,400 people who had likely died still registered, and about 700 were sent ballots. Two of them had voted in 2023, but the audit didn’t say whether they died before or after they voted. Its death records ran through mid-2024, so someone who mailed a ballot and then passed away would show up the same way. Either way, the rolls should be cleaned faster. By this year’s audit, the number of possibly deceased voters on the rolls had dropped to 70, and none of them voted.
- Signature mistakes. The same audits found a 4 percent error rate in signature checks. That’s one reason Utah now checks both a signature and an ID number.
- A double vote. This year’s audit found a Wasatch County voter who cast two ballots, one in person and one by mail, because the in-person vote wasn’t recorded in the system fast enough.
- Training and tracking gaps. Some counties skipped steps in post-election audits or made errors tracking ballots.
None of these come close to changing an election. But each one should be fixed. County clerks should get the money and staff to clean voter rolls more often, check death records faster, and make sure in-person votes are recorded instantly. The lieutenant governor’s office should keep a closer eye on counties, as the auditors recommended.
Keep the ballot coming
In 2025, the Legislature passed a law that will end universal mail voting in 2029. After that, Utahns will only get a ballot in the mail if they sign up for one, and they’ll have to sign up again every eight years. If you skip two general elections in a row, your mail ballot stops.
Most voters will probably sign up. But some won’t hear about the change until it’s too late, especially older voters, young people, and rural Utahns who live far from a clerk’s office. The Legislature’s own study found that mail voting brought big jumps in turnout in rural counties. We shouldn’t throw that away.
Utah has already added the security steps critics asked for: ID numbers on ballots, signature checks, a citizenship audit, and an earlier return deadline. Now that those checks are in place, there’s no good reason to stop mailing ballots to voters. The Legislature should repeal the opt-in and keep mailing a ballot to every active, registered voter.
Voter ID shouldn’t shut out eligible Utahns
Most Americans support voter ID, and so do we, as long as every eligible citizen can actually get one. Utah already requires ID to vote in person, and now asks for ID numbers on mail ballots. The problem is the people who fall through the cracks.
Millions of Americans don’t have the ID these laws ask for. A national survey led by the University of Maryland found about 21 million voting-age Americans don’t have a current driver’s license, and about 2.6 million have no government photo ID at all. Many more have a license with an old name or address. The people most likely to be missing an ID are young people, older people, people with disabilities, and people with lower incomes.
In Utah, that includes people you know. It includes grandparents who stopped driving, college students, people who moved recently, and families on the Navajo Nation in San Juan County, where many homes don’t have a standard street address.
Proof of citizenship is even harder. Senator Lee’s SAVE America Act would require documents like a birth certificate or passport to register. A national survey found that about 9 percent of voting-age citizens, more than 21 million people, can’t easily get to those papers. Many married women would also have trouble, because the name on their birth certificate doesn’t match the name they use now. When Kansas tried a law like this, about 31,000 eligible citizens were blocked from registering before a court struck it down.
The fix is simple. If you want people to show ID, make getting one free and easy:
- Free state ID for every eligible voter, not only for people who sign a statement saying they’re poor, as Utah’s law now requires.
- Bring ID offices to people, with mobile offices in rural and tribal areas.
- Accept many kinds of ID, including tribal IDs, student IDs from Utah schools, and other government documents.
- Keep the signature as a backup, so a missing ID number doesn’t throw out a real voter’s ballot. The Legislature took a good step this year when it kept signature checks alongside ID numbers.
- Give voters a chance to fix problems before their ballot is thrown out.
Time off to vote
Even in a mail-voting state, some Utahns need to vote in person. Some need to register on Election Day, which Utah allows. Some lost their ballot, moved, or need the accessible voting machines at a polling place. And some just want to vote in person. Vote centers are open from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. on Election Day, and for someone working a long shift or two jobs, that window can disappear fast.
Utah already has a law for this. Your employer must give you up to two hours of paid time off to vote, but only if you don’t have three hours outside of work while the polls are open. You have to ask before Election Day, and your employer can choose when you take the time.
I support this law, and Utah should keep it. It’s a fair balance. Workers who need the time get it, and employers can plan around it. Most people won’t need it, because most of us vote by mail. But no one should have to choose between a paycheck and a ballot.
The bigger problem is that many workers don’t know the law exists. The state should remind employers before every election, and employers should remind their workers, so everyone who needs the time knows how to ask for it.
Keep Utah in charge of Utah’s elections
The Constitution gives states the job of running elections, and Utah does it well. This year, the federal Justice Department sued 30 states, including Utah, for full access to their voter rolls, including private information. Lieutenant Governor Henderson has said federal agencies haven’t given clear answers about how they’d use voters’ Social Security numbers, birth dates, and driver’s license numbers.
Utah should work with the federal government to catch noncitizens and people voting in two states. But Utahns’ private data should be protected, and decisions about how Utah votes should be made in Utah.
The ideas in detail
1. Keep universal mail voting
Repeal the 2029 opt-in, and keep mailing a ballot to every active, registered voter, with the ID number and signature checks now in place.
2. Clean voter rolls, faster
Fund county clerks to check death records and moves more often. Record in-person votes instantly so no one can vote twice. Have the lieutenant governor’s office follow up on every audit finding until it’s fixed.
3. Free ID for every eligible voter
Make state ID cards free for every eligible Utah voter. Add mobile ID offices in rural and tribal areas. Accept tribal and student IDs, and keep signature checks as a backup.
4. Protect paid time off to vote
Keep Utah’s law that gives workers up to two hours of paid time off to vote when their schedules don’t leave enough time. Have the state remind employers about it before every election.
5. Prosecute real fraud
Every case of fraud should be investigated and prosecuted, whoever commits it. Fund the attorney general and county attorneys to do it.
6. Protect voters’ private data
Share what’s needed to catch illegal voting, but don’t hand over Utahns’ Social Security numbers and other private data without clear limits on how it’s used.
7. Publish the results
After every election, publish what audits found, what was fixed, and how many fraud cases were referred and prosecuted. Sunlight builds trust.
Questions people ask
Doesn’t mail voting make fraud easier?
Utah’s experience says no. The Legislature’s own study found no sign that fraud goes up when states switch to mail voting, and no significant fraud in Utah. Mail ballots are checked twice, tracked from start to finish, and kept on paper. That’s more of a paper trail than many in-person systems have.
If fraud is so rare, why bother with ID at all?
Because confidence matters, and most Utahns support ID. Checks like ID numbers and signatures help catch the rare cases and reassure people the system is sound. Voter ID makes sense. ID rules that block eligible citizens who can’t easily get the right card don’t.
Isn’t one illegal vote too many?
Yes. That’s why every case should be caught and prosecuted. But the answer to a handful of illegal votes isn’t to make it harder for hundreds of thousands of legal voters to cast their ballots.
Didn’t some noncitizens vote in Utah?
Yes, 13 out of more than 2 million voters, over seven years of elections. They were removed, the gaps were closed, and anyone who knowingly lied to vote should be held accountable. That’s the system working. It’s also a long way from the “hundreds of thousands” we’ve been told about.
Why should businesses have to give paid time off to vote?
Utah has required it since at least the 1990s, and it works. Most workers never use it, because most Utahns vote by mail. It’s there for the shift worker, the person with two jobs, or the voter who has to register or replace a lost ballot on Election Day. Two hours is a small cost for making sure every worker can vote.
The bottom line
Utah’s elections are safe, and the people who run them, many of them Republicans, have the audits to prove it. Fraud happens, but it’s rare, and when it happens we catch it. Let’s keep the system that works, fix the problems audits find, make ID free and easy for every eligible Utahn, give workers time to vote, and stop telling people their votes don’t count. They do.
Sources
- Utah Lieutenant Governor: Voter citizenship audit summary
- KPCW: Utah Lt. Gov. finds 99% of Utah voters are U.S. citizens
- KSL: New audit finds ‘small handful’ of noncitizens on Utah voter rolls
- Democracy Docket: Utah finds just 13 invalid ballots out of millions cast
- Deseret News: Here’s what Utah’s latest election audit found
- Deseret News: Yet another study finds little fraud in Utah voting
- Utah Legislative Auditor General: A Performance Audit of Utah’s Election System (2024)
- Deseret News: Utah lawmakers paid for a study on mail-in voting security
- Utah Valley University Herbert Institute: Utah election security study
- Daily Signal (Heritage Foundation): Election fraud database reaches 1,600 cases
- Heritage Foundation: No one knows the full extent of election fraud
- Brennan Center: Heritage fraud database, an assessment
- Ballotpedia: Voter turnout in United States elections
- Utah Elections: Ballot processing safeguards
- Utah Elections: Securing your mail ballot
- Salt Lake County Clerk: Election security
- Salt Lake Tribune: 95% of voters used a mail-in ballot this year
- Deseret News: Utah Legislature reforms vote by mail but rejects election oversight overhaul
- NBC News: Utah governor signs bill to phase out universal mail ballots
- Utah News Dispatch via Yahoo: What Utah’s 2025 election law does
- Deseret News: Trump vows to end mail voting before the 2026 midterms
- Deseret News: Mike Lee says mail-in voting should be restricted
- KSL: Mike Lee says postal worker endorsements create a ‘cozy arrangement’
- Deseret News: Sen. Lee responds to Lt. Gov. Henderson on federal election inquiries
- KUER: Utah mail ballots and rural voters in the 2026 midterm
- VoteRiders: Millions of Americans lack a current driver’s license
- University of Maryland Center for Democracy and Civic Engagement: Who lacks ID
- Brennan Center: 21.3 million citizens don’t have ready access to proof of citizenship
- Ballotpedia: Time off work for voting
- Utah Code 20A-3a-105: Employee’s right to time off for election
- Utah News Dispatch via Herald Extra: Tighter deadlines for mail ballots