A Degree Shouldn't Come With a Lifetime of Debt
At a glance
- Utah students carry the lowest average debt in America, and fewer of them borrow at all.
- Federal undergraduate loans now carry 6.52 percent interest. On a $30,000 loan, that’s about $10,900 in interest over ten years.
- Cap undergraduate loan rates at 4 percent, and make colleges share the risk when they raise prices faster than inflation.
- More college credit in high school, more need-based aid, and a loan-repayment bonus for teachers who stay in Utah classrooms.
Where we stand
Utah is lucky. We have some of the most affordable universities in the country. The University of Utah is a top research university with the lowest tuition of any of its peers in the West. Utah State, Utah Valley, Weber State, Southern Utah, Utah Tech, and Snow are all good schools at a reasonable price. BYU is kept affordable for Latter-day Saint students by the Church. And Utah has a strong job market, with plenty of work for students who want to pay their way.
That’s why Utah students borrow less than students anywhere else in America. It’s something to be proud of, and something to protect.
But low debt for Utah on average doesn’t mean low debt for every Utahn. Plenty of students still borrow, especially those who don’t get help from family, who go on to graduate school, or who pay rent in one of the most expensive housing markets in the country. And when they graduate, many go into jobs like teaching where Utah pay hasn’t kept up with the national average.
We also want to be careful about how we talk about student debt. Many of us went to college with tuition kept low by Utah taxpayers or by the Church. That’s a real gift. It’s not a reason to look down on people who had to borrow more. Most of them did exactly what we told them to do: work hard, go to school, and invest in their future.
So our goal is simple: keep what works in Utah, make borrowing fair for those who need to, and find more ways to bring the cost down.
What we want to accomplish
- Make federal student loans affordable, with undergraduate rates capped at 4 percent.
- Stop tuition from chasing loan limits, by making colleges share the risk when they raise prices faster than inflation.
- Keep Utah tuition increases at or below inflation.
- Expand concurrent enrollment so more students finish high school with a semester or more of college already done.
- Fund need-based aid so Utah’s Promise scholarship reaches more students and goes further.
- Help teachers and other public servants pay off their loans if they stay and serve in Utah.
- Treat borrowers with respect, not suspicion.
What we shouldn’t do
- Make college “free” for everyone, including families who can easily afford it.
- Cancel debt across the board without fixing what made it so expensive.
- Keep raising loan limits without asking what it does to tuition.
- Cut need-based aid for students who can least afford college.
- Look down on borrowers. Most did what they were told was the responsible thing.
Utah is a great place to go to college
Utah’s public universities are a bargain by national standards. In 2025-26, the average public four-year university charged in-state students $11,950 in tuition and fees. All four of Utah’s biggest public universities came in below that. Weber State and Utah Valley charged about $6,600. Utah State charged about $8,800. Even the University of Utah, a top research university, charged about $10,800, the lowest of any major public research university in the West.
BYU charged Latter-day Saint students about $6,900 a year, because the Church covers much of the cost with tithing. Students who aren’t members of the Church pay twice that, which is still a good price for a private university.
Utah’s board of higher education also keeps a close eye on tuition. For this school year, it approved an average increase of about 2.8 percent, and trimmed what some schools asked for.
That’s why Utah students graduate with less debt. For years, Utah has had the lowest average student debt in the country and the smallest share of students who borrow at all.
But Utahns still borrow
Low tuition is only part of the story. Rent, food, books, and getting to class often cost more than tuition does. At the University of Utah, the school estimates housing and food alone cost about $19,000 a year, almost twice what tuition costs.
Utah’s housing has gotten very expensive. Our housing costs rank among the highest in the country, and the cost of rent near campus can push students to borrow even when tuition is low. My housing position covers how to build more homes Utahns can afford.
Graduate school is another story. Utah’s future doctors, nurses, lawyers, counselors, and principals often have to borrow a lot more than undergraduates do. And starting this year, Congress ended the federal Grad PLUS loan for new borrowers and put new limits on what graduate students can borrow. Some will turn to private loans with higher rates and fewer protections.
Paying it back on a Utah paycheck
Debt is only a problem if your paycheck can’t cover it. For many Utahns, that’s the challenge.
Utah’s typical salary was about $48,600 in 2024. Teachers are a good example of the squeeze. Utah’s starting teacher pay is now among the best in the country, in the top five nationally. That’s real progress, and lawmakers deserve credit for it. But the raises flatten out. Utah’s average teacher salary was about $67,600 in 2024, below the national average of about $72,000. My public schools position covers how to fix that.
So a young teacher in Utah might start strong, but still spend years paying off loans on a salary that falls behind teachers in other states over time. The same is true for social workers, nurses in rural hospitals, and other jobs Utah depends on.
The interest rate matters
Federal student loans for undergraduates now carry a 6.52 percent fixed interest rate for the 2026-27 school year. Parents who borrow through the Parent PLUS program pay 9.07 percent. Those rates are near the highest they’ve been in years.
On a $30,000 loan paid off over ten years, a 6.52 percent rate means about $10,900 in interest. At 4 percent, it would be about $6,400. That’s $4,500 a borrower could put toward a first home, a car, or their own kids’ education.
The federal government sets these rates each spring based on what it costs the Treasury to borrow, plus an extra markup. Undergraduate rates should be capped at 4 percent, so a student loan is a tool to build a future, not a burden that follows people for decades. This will cost taxpayers money, and it should be paid for in the federal budget rather than added to the deficit. But helping young people get on their feet is an investment that pays back.
Stop tuition from chasing loan limits
There’s a reason to be careful about just handing out more money. In 1987, President Reagan’s education secretary, William Bennett, argued that colleges raise tuition because federal aid lets them. Researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York later tested the idea. They found that when Washington raised how much students could borrow in subsidized loans, colleges raised tuition by about 60 cents for every extra dollar. The effect was biggest for expensive programs, private colleges, and for-profit and two-year schools.
That doesn’t mean every school does it. Utah’s public colleges have kept tuition increases modest. But nationally, it’s a real problem, and students pay for it with more debt.
The incentives should change:
- Make colleges share the risk. When a college raises tuition faster than inflation and its students can’t repay their loans, the college should pay back part of the loss. Today taxpayers and students carry all of that risk.
- Don’t raise loan limits without a check on prices. Any increase in federal loan limits should come with a requirement that schools hold down tuition.
- Show students the real price. Every school should give students a clear, simple estimate of what they’ll pay and what graduates in their program typically earn.
- Keep Utah’s tuition increases at or below inflation, and keep the board of higher education’s careful review.
Other ways to make college affordable
The cheapest loan is the one you never need to take out. Utah already leads in some of these, and can build on them.
College credit in high school. Through concurrent enrollment, more than 61,000 Utah high school students earned college credit in the 2024-25 school year, saving their families about $125 million in tuition. Every high school, including rural ones, should be able to offer enough courses for students to finish a semester or more of college before they graduate.
Credit for what you already know. Utah colleges now give credit for work experience, training, and industry certifications. Students saved about $72 million that way. It should keep expanding, especially for adults going back to school.
Need-based aid that goes further. Utah’s Promise scholarship helps students with financial need, but it’s small. It awarded about 3,100 scholarships averaging about $1,800 each, while the state’s main achievement-based scholarship is more than three times as large. Growing Promise would let more students with real need count on it.
Technical colleges and short programs. Not every good career needs a four-year degree. Utah’s technical colleges train electricians, welders, nurses’ aides, and IT workers at a fraction of the cost. Their tuition should stay low, and students should know these options exist.
Lower-cost textbooks. Free and low-cost course materials can save students hundreds of dollars a year. Utah’s colleges should use them wherever they can.
Campus jobs. Utah students work, and that’s a good thing. Federal work-study should be protected, and employers should be encouraged to offer flexible hours and help with tuition.
Help those who serve
People who teach our kids, care for our sick, and work in public service shouldn’t have to choose between that work and paying off their loans.
The federal Public Service Loan Forgiveness program forgives remaining federal loans after ten years of payments for teachers, nurses at nonprofit hospitals, police, and other public servants. It should be protected, and Utahns should know how to use it.
Utah should also add a loan-repayment bonus for teachers who stay in Utah classrooms. A teacher who stays five years would get help paying down their loans, with extra help for those who teach in rural schools or hard-to-fill subjects like math, science, and special education. Keeping a good teacher is far cheaper than training a new one.
The ideas in detail
1. Cap undergraduate loan rates at 4 percent
Set federal undergraduate loan rates at no more than 4 percent, paid for in the federal budget.
2. Make colleges share the risk
Colleges that raise tuition faster than inflation should pay back part of the loss when their students can’t repay federal loans.
3. Tie loan limits to price restraint
Don’t raise federal loan limits without a requirement that schools hold tuition down.
4. Clear prices and outcomes
Give every student a simple estimate of what they’ll pay and what graduates in their program typically earn.
5. Keep Utah tuition in check
Keep Utah’s public college tuition increases at or below inflation.
6. Expand college credit in high school
Make sure every Utah high school can offer enough concurrent enrollment courses for students to finish a semester or more of college before they graduate.
7. Grow need-based aid
Expand Utah’s Promise scholarship so more students with financial need can count on it.
8. A Utah teacher loan-repayment bonus
Help teachers who stay five years in Utah classrooms pay down their loans, with extra help in rural schools and hard-to-fill subjects.
9. Protect Public Service Loan Forgiveness
Keep the federal program that forgives loans for teachers, nurses, and other public servants after ten years of service.
Questions people ask
Why should taxpayers help pay for someone else’s loan?
Because Utah taxpayers already help pay for college, and it’s one of the best investments we make. Lower rates help young people buy homes, start businesses, and raise families here. And a borrower who can repay is better for taxpayers than one who falls behind.
Won’t cheaper loans just make colleges raise tuition?
That’s a fair worry, and it’s why lower rates need to come with a check on prices. Colleges that raise tuition faster than inflation should share in the losses when students can’t repay.
Why not just cancel student debt?
Canceling debt across the board helps people who don’t need it, including high earners, and does nothing to stop the next generation from borrowing just as much. The better answer is to fix the system: lower rates, hold down tuition, and help people who serve.
I paid off my loans. Why should anyone get help now?
Good for you. That took real sacrifice. Nobody is asking you to pay off someone else’s loans. The goal is for the next generation to borrow less and pay a fair rate, so fewer families face the struggle you did.
Isn’t Utah already doing fine?
Utah is doing better than most states, and it should stay that way. But the cost of living near campus keeps going up, federal loan rates are high, and Utah pay in some jobs still lags. Doing fine on average isn’t the same as doing fine for every student.
The bottom line
Utah has built something special: good colleges that families can actually afford. Let’s protect it. Give students loans at a rate they can manage, make colleges think twice before raising prices just because loans let them, help more students start college in high school, and reward the teachers and public servants who stay and serve. And let’s never look down on a neighbor who had to borrow to build a better life.
Sources
- College Board: Trends in College Pricing and Student Aid 2025
- Utah System of Higher Education: 2025-26 tuition and fees memo
- Utah System of Higher Education: Tuition and fee increases remain modest
- University of Utah: Tuition and fees hearing, March 2026
- University of Utah: Tuition costs for 2026-27
- Deseret News: Utah’s higher education board approves tuition increases
- BYU: Cost of attendance
- BYU: How much is tuition?
- Deseret News: Utah has the nation’s lowest average student debt
- KSL: Utah ranks best in US for student debt
- Uni2Study: Cost of attending college in Utah
- KSL: Utah’s housing costs remain among the highest in the nation
- NerdWallet: What’s happening with federal student loans
- Webull/Dow Jones: 2026-27 federal student loan rates
- Newsweek: Student loan rates rise for 2026-27, Grad PLUS ends
- The College Investor: What changed for borrowers on July 1, 2026
- CUNY: One Big Beautiful Bill Act changes to federal aid
- NPR via OPB: NEA teacher salary report, 2026
- Puresource summary of NEA 2026 starting salary data
- Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget: The Scoop on Salaries
- K-12 Dive: NEA average teacher salaries, 2023–24
- Federal Reserve Bank of New York: Credit supply and the rise in college tuition
- Marketplace: Does financial aid really drive up tuition?
- Deseret News: Utah high school students in concurrent enrollment
- Utah System of Higher Education: Students earn credit for prior learning
- Utah Governor’s Office of Planning and Budget: The story on scholarships