Clean Air Is a Utah Value

At a glance

  • Cars, trucks, and other engines make almost half of the pollution in a typical winter inversion.
  • Free transit on bad-air days. When fares came off in February 2022, weekday FrontRunner ridership jumped 36 percent.
  • Make the carpool lane a carpool lane again. Charge solo drivers a real price at rush hour, keep carpools and buses free, and put the extra toll money toward finishing FrontRunner.
  • Chargers where people live and work, a rebate for electric yard tools, and Utah’s own standards for big polluters, whatever Washington decides.

15 min read

Where we stand

Clean air shouldn’t be a partisan issue. Every Utahn has seen the gray lid settle over the valley in January, and plenty of us have watched a child or a parent struggle to breathe through it.

The good news is that Utah’s air is much cleaner than it was 20 years ago, even as our population has boomed. The bad news is that we’re not done. The Salt Lake area is still among the 15 worst metro areas in America for ozone, and winter inversions still trap soot in our valleys.

Cars and trucks are the biggest single source of the problem along the Wasatch Front. So the ideas here start there: make it easier and cheaper to leave the car at home, make the carpool lane work the way it was meant to, and help people who want to drive electric find a place to charge. Utah should also keep holding big polluters to strong standards of its own, no matter what happens in Washington.

None of this means telling anyone what to drive or where to live. It means giving Utahns better choices and paying for them in a way that’s fair.

What we want to accomplish

  1. Free transit on bad-air days, paid for by the state, so riding is the easy choice when the air is worst.
  2. Finish FrontRunner double tracking so trains come more often and more people can count on them.
  3. A carpool lane that’s for carpools. Carpools always ride free. Solo drivers who want in should pay a rush-hour toll high enough to keep the lane moving.
  4. Put extra toll money toward transit, starting with FrontRunner, and report every dollar.
  5. More chargers in the valley, especially at apartments, condos, workplaces, and park-and-ride lots.
  6. A standing rebate for electric yard tools, including lawn mowers.
  7. Keep Utah’s own rules strong for big polluters, whatever the federal government decides.

What we shouldn’t do

  • Ban gas cars or tell people what to drive. Better choices work better than mandates.
  • Raise everyone’s taxes to pay for it. Drivers who choose to pay for a faster lane can help pay for transit.
  • Blame it all on someone else. Pollution from overseas is real, but most of what we breathe on a bad day is made right here, and that part is up to us.
  • Pretend we’re done because the air is better than it was in 2002.
  • Let the carpool lane turn into a cheap fast lane for anyone with a toll pass.

Why this matters

It’s about our health. A 2020 study by researchers from BYU, the University of Utah, and Utah State estimated that air pollution causes between 2,500 and 8,000 early deaths in Utah each year and shortens the average Utahn’s life by about two years. The same study put the cost to Utah’s economy at about $1.9 billion a year.

It’s about our economy. Companies and workers notice the haze. A reputation for dirty air makes it harder to recruit the people and businesses that keep Utah growing.

It’s about our kids. Children breathe faster than adults and spend more time outside. Every red-air day means some kids stay in at recess and some parents spend the night at the hospital with an asthma attack.

How far we’ve come, and how far we have to go

Fewer bad-air days than 20 years ago, but not enoughDays per year Salt Lake County’s air quality index topped 100 (unhealthy for sensitive groups or worse)02040602000: 52 days20002001: 54 days2002: 66 days2003: 39 days2004: 55 days2005: 60 days20052006: 54 days2007: 63 days2008: 33 days2009: 37 days2010: 23 days20102011: 30 days2012: 17 days2013: 5 days2014: 22 days2015: 27 days20152016: 27 days2017: 44 days2018: 41 days2019: 16 days2020: 20 days20202021: 47 days2022: 22 days2023: 16 days20236654716
Red bars are years with 40 or more bad days. Swings from year to year follow the weather and wildfire smoke. Source: Utah State University Institute of Land, Water, and Air, from EPA Air Quality Index daily values.

Utah has made real progress. In the early 2000s, Salt Lake County saw 50 or 60 days a year when the air was unhealthy for people with asthma, older adults, and children. In recent years that number has usually been closer to 20. Cleaner cars, cleaner fuel, tighter rules on industry, and wood-burning limits on bad-air days all helped, even as hundreds of thousands of new people moved here.

But the trend isn’t a straight line. In 2021, wildfire smoke and summer ozone pushed the county back up to 47 bad days. And on ozone, the Salt Lake area still gets an F. The American Lung Association’s latest report found Salt Lake County averaged about 21 days a year of unhealthy ozone, ranking the region 13th worst in the country.

Where the pollution comes from

Cars and trucks are the biggest source of winter smogShare of pollution in a typical Wasatch Front winter inversionCars, trucks, trains, planesCars, trucks, trains, planes: 48%48%Homes & small businessesHomes & small businesses: 39%39%Big industryBig industry: 13%13%
Source: Utah Division of Air Quality, as reported by the Utah Governor’s Office.

On a typical winter inversion day, Utah’s air quality agency estimates:

  • Mobile sources make about 48 percent. That’s cars, trucks, trains, and planes.
  • Area sources make about 39 percent. That’s homes, small businesses, furnaces, water heaters, and wood smoke.
  • Big industry makes about 13 percent. That’s refineries, mines, and other large plants.

Big industry has already cut its emissions by about half since the mid-1990s. Cars have gotten much cleaner, too, but there are a lot more of them, and we drive them a lot more miles. That’s why getting cars off the road on the worst days does so much good.

Free transit when the air is worst

When transit was free, more people rodeWeekday ridership in Free Fare February 2022, compared with JanuaryFrontRunnerFrontRunner: +36%+36%BusesBuses: +19%+19%All UTA serviceAll UTA service: +16%+16%TRAXTRAX: +13%+13%
Weekdays compared with the last five weekdays of January 2022. Source: Utah Transit Authority, Free Fare February Final Report (April 2022).

In February 2022, the Utah Transit Authority made every bus and train free for a month. People rode. Compared to January, weekday ridership rose about 16 percent across the system, 19 percent on buses, and 36 percent on FrontRunner. Saturday ridership rose 58 percent. UTA estimated the month kept about 68 tons of pollution out of the air.

Free fares aren’t new to Utah. The Legislature has paid for free fare days on bad-air days before, but only a handful at a time and only when lawmakers set aside the money. It should be automatic: when the state calls a mandatory no-burn day because of bad air, fares should come off, and the state should cover the lost revenue.

Fares pay for only a small part of what transit costs, so a few free days a year is affordable. And it sends the right message: on the worst days, leaving the car at home should be the easy choice.

Free fares only help if the trains and buses are there. That’s why FrontRunner matters so much.

Finish FrontRunner

FrontRunner runs from Ogden to Provo, but most of the line has only one track. Trains have to wait for each other, which limits how often they can run and makes delays spread. The FrontRunner 2X project would add double track and new trains so service can come much more often.

The federal government has pledged about $1.28 billion, and the state has committed money too. But in October, UDOT told lawmakers the $3.2 billion project still has a $564 million funding gap. Utah should close it, because a train that comes every 15 minutes gets far more riders than one that comes every half hour. And tolls paid by solo drivers in the express lane can help.

Make the carpool lane a carpool lane

The I-15 express lane was built to get people to carpool. Two or more people in a car ride free. Solo drivers can buy their way in with a toll, but only if the lane has room to spare. The goal, in UDOT’s own words, is to keep the lane moving at about 55 miles an hour so carpooling pays off.

The problem is that the price is often too low to matter. Tolls run from 25 cents to $2 per zone, and outside the busiest minutes they often sit near the bottom of that range. When a solo driver can use the lane for less than a dollar, the lane fills up, slows down, and the reward for carpooling disappears. Cheating is a problem, too. UDOT has said it’s seen some of the highest carpool lane violation rates in the country.

If Utah is going to charge a toll, it should be a toll that works. That means:

  • Raise the cap so the price can climb high enough at rush hour to keep the lane at 55 miles an hour.
  • Set a real rush-hour minimum, so solo drivers pay something meaningful when the regular lanes are jammed.
  • Keep carpools, buses, and motorcycles free, always.
  • Use cameras to catch cheaters, so drivers who follow the rules aren’t stuck behind those who don’t.

A higher price will mean fewer solo drivers in the lane, but more money from each one. That money should go somewhere useful.

Toll money, not tax dollars

Today’s low tolls don’t bring in much. A toll with real teeth would bring in more. By my rough math, a toll several times higher than today’s could raise several million dollars a year more. Borrowed against over 30 years, that could cover something like a fifth to a quarter of FrontRunner’s funding gap. It won’t close the gap by itself, but it’s real money that wouldn’t have to come from taxpayers.

Federal law sets limits on how money from an interstate toll lane can be spent. Running and maintaining the lane comes first. After that, extra money can go to other transportation projects the federal government allows, which includes transit. It should go to FrontRunner first, and UDOT should be required to publish every year how much the lane collected and where each dollar went.

The idea is simple. Drivers who choose to pay for a faster trip help pay for the train that takes cars off the road. Everyone else gets cleaner air, and nobody’s taxes go up to pay for it.

Chargers where people live and work

More Utahns are driving electric. Utah had about 52,000 electric cars registered in 2024, and the number keeps climbing. Electric cars put out no tailpipe pollution, which matters most on an inversion day, when tailpipe exhaust is trapped right where we breathe.

Fast chargers along our highways are getting better. The gap now is in the valley, where people actually live. If you own a house with a garage, charging is easy. If you rent an apartment, live in a condo, or park on the street, it often isn’t. The federal tax credit for installing chargers ended this summer, so Utah’s own programs matter more than ever.

Utah’s charging dollars should focus on:

  • Apartments and condos, so renters and condo owners can charge at home like homeowners do.
  • Workplaces, so people can charge while they’re at work.
  • Park-and-ride lots and transit stations, so a short electric drive can connect to a train or bus.
  • Neighborhoods that have few chargers today, so the benefit isn’t limited to a few parts of the valley.

My energy position covers chargers along Utah’s highways, a right to charge for renters and condo owners, and keeping power bills low.

Electric yard tools

Gas lawn mowers, leaf blowers, and string trimmers are small, but they add up. Utah’s air quality agency says gas yard equipment puts out about 8 tons a day of the chemicals that form summer ozone along the northern Wasatch Front. All the big industry in the area puts out about 6.

Utah already runs a program called Charge Your Yard that helps people trade gas yard tools for electric ones. It’s popular, and it sells out. But it covers only handheld tools for residents, not lawn mowers, and it depends on money that comes and goes. It should be a standing rebate, open to every Utahn along the Wasatch Front, with mowers included.

Hold big polluters to Utah’s own standards

Big industry is only about 13 percent of winter pollution, but that’s still a lot of pollution, and some plants sit right next to neighborhoods.

This spring, the EPA proposed to stop moving the northern Wasatch Front into a tougher “serious” ozone category. The EPA said the area would have met the standard on time if not for pollution blowing in from other countries, mostly Asia. Utah’s air quality agency and Senator John Curtis supported the change, and they have a fair point. Ozone from overseas is real, and Utah shouldn’t lose highway money over pollution it can’t control.

But the federal label doesn’t change the air we breathe. Whatever the EPA decides, Utah should keep its own plan to cut ozone and soot on track, and keep holding the biggest sources to strong standards. That includes plants like US Magnesium on the Great Salt Lake, which federal regulators added to the ozone area this year.

The ideas in detail

1. Free fares on bad-air days, automatically

When the state calls a mandatory no-burn day for bad air, UTA buses, TRAX, and FrontRunner should be free. The Legislature should set aside a standing fund to cover the lost fares, so it happens every time without a new bill each year.

2. Close FrontRunner’s funding gap

Make finishing FrontRunner double tracking a top state priority. Use tolls paid by solo drivers in the express lane to cover part of the gap, and work with Utah’s congressional delegation to keep the federal share on track.

3. Carpools first in the express lane

Raise the toll cap and set a real rush-hour minimum so the lane stays at 55 miles an hour. Keep carpools, buses, and motorcycles free. Use cameras to catch drivers who cheat.

4. Put toll money to work, and show the receipts

After running and maintaining the lane, put extra toll money toward FrontRunner and other transit, as federal law allows. Require UDOT to publish each year how much the lane collected and where every dollar went.

5. Chargers where people live and work

Focus state charging dollars on apartments, condos, workplaces, park-and-ride lots, and neighborhoods with few chargers today.

6. A standing electric yard tool rebate

Make Charge Your Yard permanent, add lawn mowers, and open it to every resident and lawn care business along the Wasatch Front.

7. Utah’s own standards for big sources

Keep Utah’s plan to cut ozone and soot on track whatever federal label we’re given, and hold the biggest polluters, including US Magnesium, to strong standards.

Questions people ask

Isn’t a higher toll just another tax?

No. Nobody has to pay it. Carpools, buses, and motorcycles ride free, and everyone else can stay in the regular lanes for free. A toll is a price for a choice, and the people who choose to pay it get a faster trip. Better that money help pay for FrontRunner than raise taxes on everyone.

Won’t a higher toll just help people who can afford it?

That’s a fair worry. The answer is to keep the lane’s main purpose front and center: carpools ride free, so anyone can use it for nothing by sharing a ride. And when the toll money helps pay for better transit, it helps the people who can least afford to drive most of all.

Why should Utah pay for free fares?

Because the days transit would be free are the days the air is worst, and that’s when getting even a few thousand cars off the road matters most. Fares cover only a small share of what transit costs, so a few free days a year is cheap compared to the cost of the pollution.

Isn’t most of our pollution from China?

Some of our summer ozone does blow in from overseas, and Utah shouldn’t be punished for that. But in a winter inversion, the pollution trapped in our valleys is ours. Cars, homes, and local industry make almost all of it. We can’t control China. We can control what we put in our own air.

Isn’t the air already getting better?

Yes, and that’s worth celebrating. But Utah is still adding people fast, and the Salt Lake area still ranks among the worst in the country for ozone. If we stop now, growth will eat up the progress we’ve made.

Do electric cars really help if the power comes from coal?

Utah’s power is getting cleaner every year, and solar became our biggest source of electricity this year. But even when the power comes from a plant far away, an electric car puts out nothing from its tailpipe. On an inversion day, that matters, because the pollution from a tailpipe is trapped right where we live and breathe.

The bottom line

Clean air is something every Utahn can agree on. We’ve already shown we can grow and clean up at the same time. The next step is giving people better ways to get around: free transit on the worst days, a FrontRunner that comes more often, a carpool lane that actually rewards carpooling, and chargers where people live and work. Let the drivers who want a faster lane help pay for the train, keep strong rules for the biggest polluters, and don’t wait for Washington to solve a problem we can see from our own front porch.

Sources