Outside Money Poured Into Utah This Year. It Didn’t Come From Just One Side.
A Deseret News story says a network of out-of-state Democratic donors laid the groundwork for Utah's blue wave. But the story leaves out the out-of-state money on the right. Utahns deserve to know who's paying for every campaign, on every side.
On Nov. 18, the Deseret News published a long story about a network of Democratic-leaning donors and groups that spent money to flip Republican seats in Utah’s Legislature this year. It follows the money from Utah groups up to national funds, including ones tied to George Soros.
After reading it, I fact-checked what I could. Much of it holds up. Some of it doesn’t, and a few important things are missing. Here’s what I found.
What the story gets right
The money is real. The groups and dollar amounts come from public campaign reports and tax filings. The Fairness Project, a national group based in Washington, D.C., really did put about $1.7 million into the campaign against Amendment B. Tax filings show George Soros’s Open Society Action Fund gave the Sixteen Thirty Fund about $68 million over five years. And some of the groups involved don’t have to say who their donors are.
The swing was historic. By one widely cited measure, Utah moved toward Democrats in U.S. House races more than any other state compared with 2022. Republicans lost their supermajority in the Utah House.
If I’d been a Republican lawmaker who lost to a challenger backed by out-of-state money I’d never heard of, I’d be frustrated too. That frustration is fair. So is the question of who’s paying for Utah’s campaigns.
What doesn’t add up
No conservative equivalent? Former House Speaker Greg Hughes told the paper there’s nothing like this network on the right, and the story doesn’t challenge him. But out-of-state money on the right has been active in Utah too, and often just as hard to trace:
- Americans for Prosperity, a national conservative group backed by the Koch network, spent about $100,000 supporting Amendment B. Like the Fairness Project, it doesn’t disclose its donors.
- Make Liberty Win, a Virginia-based PAC, put $100,000 into mailers, texts, and calls against Utah Senate President Stuart Adams in this year’s Republican primary. His own campaign called them out-of-state dark money tactics. Adams lost.
- A North Carolina megadonor spent $2.5 million to help elect Senator John Curtis, then launched a group in Utah to boost Republican candidates, working alongside other Utah groups with the same goal.
- Governing Group, a Utah PAC that backs Republican candidates, faced a complaint last year over a $100,000 donation from an out-of-state group that doesn’t name its donors.
- The Club for Growth, a national conservative group in Washington, has spent heavily in Utah’s Republican Senate primaries for years.
Some of these groups back moderate Republicans and some back hardliners. Some help incumbents and some try to oust them. But every one of them is money from outside Utah trying to shape who represents Utah. That’s the same thing the story describes on the left.
The candidates’ own campaign reports tell the same story, in two ways.
Who gave. Utahns made about 2,400 itemized contributions to the four Democratic House nominees, nearly three times the roughly 870 they made to the four Republican nominees. The Democratic gifts were smaller, too, averaging about $690 compared with about $1,570 on the Republican side. Republicans also leaned more on donors outside Utah: about $1.15 million of their itemized money came from out of state, almost twice the $610,000 the Democrats raised from outside Utah. In other words, Democrats drew more Utahns giving smaller amounts, while Republicans relied more on bigger checks from fewer donors, many of them out of state.
Who else paid. Federal filings show the Republican nominees took in about $3 million in direct contributions from political action committees, almost nine times the $340,000 the Democrats received. Outside groups also spent on their own. Super PACs spent about $2.7 million supporting Ben McAdams, most of it in his Democratic primary. Outside groups spent about $1.8 million supporting Republican nominees Celeste Maloy and Blake Moore, and another $785,000 against them, much of it in their own Republican primaries. Most of these groups are national, and many don’t have to say who funds them.
That’s not a story about one side. Outside money ran through Utah’s elections on the left and the right, in primaries and in November.
The Soros framing. The story traces money from Utah candidates up the chain to a fund backed by George Soros, which is a big part of why it got attention. The $68 million is real, but filings show the Sixteen Thirty Fund took in about $432 million in grants over those years, and its biggest funder wasn’t Soros. Naming one famous billionaire makes a better headline than a full list of donors.
Amendment B. The story describes the Fairness Project as a national abortion-rights group. It has spent heavily on abortion measures, but it also backs things like Medicaid expansion. That matters here, because Amendment B would have required 60 percent for tax-related initiatives, and Utah’s own Medicaid expansion initiative passed with just over 50 percent. Utah voters rejected Amendment B by more than 20 points. Outside money didn’t make 6 in 10 Utahns vote no. They had their own reasons.
The bottom line
Outside money shaped Utah’s 2026 elections from both directions, and much of it came through groups that never name their donors, the Fairness Project and Americans for Prosperity alike. Following only one side’s money just gives each party an excuse to ignore its own.
The fix works the same for everyone: any group spending serious money on a Utah race should have to name its big donors. Arizona voters passed a law like that in 2022, and a federal appeals court upheld it this fall.
And money didn’t create the anger behind this year’s wave. Utahns were already frustrated with a Legislature that overrode voters on redistricting and tried to make ballot initiatives harder to pass. Even House Speaker Mike Schultz pointed to frustration with President Trump’s policies. Outside groups spent money to channel that frustration. They didn’t invent it.