Uncle Sam Shouldn't Be Your Business Partner

Washington now owns pieces of dozens of private companies and takes a cut of some of their sales. Whatever you call it, that's government picking winners and losers. Utah was built on free enterprise, and the rules should be the same for every business, not cut deal by deal in the Oval Office.

· 7 min read

For most of my life, Republicans and Democrats agreed on at least one thing: the government shouldn’t own American companies. Washington could set the rules, collect taxes, and step in during a real crisis. But it didn’t buy stock, sit in the boardroom, or take a cut of the sales.

That line is fading fast, and very few people are talking about it.

Washington’s new stock portfolio

Washington's growing stock portfolioShare of each business the federal government has taken, 2025–2026Korea Zinc's Tennessee refineryKorea Zinc's Tennessee refinery: 40%40%MP Materials (rare earths)MP Materials (rare earths): 15%15%Intel (computer chips)Intel (computer chips): 10%10%Lithium AmericasLithium Americas: 10%10%Trilogy MetalsTrilogy Metals: 10%10%USA Rare EarthUSA Rare Earth: 10%10%
A sample of the deals. The Council on Foreign Relations counts 39 federal investment deals worth $27.7 billion since January 2025. The government also holds a “golden share” in U.S. Steel that gives it veto power over some decisions. Sources: Benzinga; Foreign Policy; The National; Barchart.

In August 2025, the administration turned billions of dollars in chip grants into a 10% stake in Intel, making the federal government the company’s largest shareholder. It didn’t stop there. The government has since taken stakes in companies that mine rare earths, lithium, and copper, build computer chips, and make missiles. It holds a “golden share” in U.S. Steel that gives it a say over some of the company’s decisions.

By the Council on Foreign Relations’ count, the administration has signed 39 deals worth $27.7 billion since January 2025. And the President has made clear he wants more. “I will make deals like that for our Country all day long,” he wrote.

A cut of the sale

Owning stock is one thing. Taking a cut of a company’s sales is another.

For years, the U.S. blocked Nvidia from selling its most advanced AI chips to China, for national security reasons. Then in December 2025, the President announced Nvidia could sell its powerful H200 chips to China after all, as long as 25% of the money goes to the U.S. government. Over the summer, the price had been 15%. Because the Constitution doesn’t allow taxes on exports, the fee was set up as a tariff on the chips when they pass through the U.S. for testing on their way to China.

Think about what that means. Either selling those chips to China is a threat to our security, or it isn’t. If it is, no fee makes it safe. If it isn’t, then the government has no business taking a quarter of the sale. National security shouldn’t have a price tag.

Oil, shipping lanes, and a habit of deal-making

The same instinct shows up overseas.

After U.S. forces removed Nicolás Maduro in January, the administration said it would control Venezuela’s oil sales “indefinitely” and hold the money in U.S.-controlled accounts. The first proceeds were parked in an account in Qatar. The President said Venezuela would use the money to buy only American-made products.

To be fair, the administration now reports that it has sent about 99% of the $12.26 billion in sales back to Venezuela, after Venezuelan officials asked for approval to spend it. But the U.S. government is still acting as the sales agent for another country’s oil, deciding who gets to buy it and how the money gets spent. And the report blacked out the names of all 20 companies that bought the oil. Americans deserve to know who is getting those deals.

Then in July, the President announced the U.S. would charge a 20% fee on all cargo shipped through the Strait of Hormuz, the waterway where Iran had been trying to charge tolls of its own. For a single supertanker, that could have meant about $34 million a trip. America has defended free passage through that strait for decades. A day later, the President dropped the fee and said Gulf countries would make investment deals in the U.S. instead.

Call it what it is

When the government owns a piece of the means of production, there’s a word for that. I’m not the first to say so. When the Intel deal was announced, Republican Senator Rand Paul asked, “If socialism is government owning the means of production, wouldn’t the government owning part of Intel be a step toward socialism?” Conservative radio host Erick Erickson called it “socialism dressed in patriotic language.” And Bernie Sanders, who calls himself a democratic socialist, praised the deal. He and Elizabeth Warren had proposed something similar back in 2022.

Economists have a more polite name for it: state capitalism, the kind of system China runs. Whatever you call it, it’s the government picking winners and losers.

The case for it, and why it falls short

There’s a real argument on the other side, and it deserves a fair hearing. China controls most of the world’s supply of rare earths and other minerals we need for weapons, phones, and cars. Building our own supply is a genuine national security priority, and I support it. The administration also argues that if taxpayers are putting up the money, taxpayers should share in the upside. That’s not a crazy idea.

We’ve done this before, too. During the 2008 financial crisis, Washington took stakes in General Motors, Chrysler, and AIG. But those were emergency rescues, approved by Congress, and the government sold its shares and got out.

What’s happening now is different, in four ways:

  • There’s no exit plan. These are open-ended stakes, not temporary rescues.
  • There’s no vote. Deals are cut one at a time by the executive branch, not set by laws that apply to everyone.
  • The referee is also a player. When the government owns part of a company, it has a reason to go easy on that company and tough on its competitors. Every agency that regulates Intel now works for Intel’s largest shareholder.
  • It invites pay-to-play. When a company’s fate depends on a deal with the White House, the companies with the best connections win. A family-owned business in Ogden or St. George will never get that meeting.

Utah was built on free enterprise. Our economy runs on small businesses that compete on a level field, without a lobbyist in Washington. They deserve the same rules as the big guys, not a market where the government is quietly a partner to their biggest competitors.

What we should do instead

We can build our own supply chains and stay tough on China without the government buying up companies:

  • Make Congress approve it. No federal stake in a private company without a vote of Congress, and no fees on private sales that Congress hasn’t written into law.
  • Plan the exit. Any stake the government takes should come with a date to sell it, like the 2008 rescues.
  • Put it all in the open. Publish every deal, its terms, and every buyer of government-controlled oil, in one public report each year.
  • Keep national security decisions about security. Export decisions should be made on the merits, with no fees attached.
  • Use the tools we already have. Grants and loans can come with strings attached: build here, hire here, and pay the money back if you don’t. We don’t need to own the company to protect the taxpayer.
  • Defend free passage at sea. America has always kept international waters open to everyone, free of charge. We should keep it that way.

The bottom line

I believe in markets. I believe in competition. And I believe the government’s job is to set fair rules and enforce them for everyone, not to pick favorites and take a cut. If a Democratic president were buying up companies and charging a fee on private sales, Republicans would rightly call it socialism. The rules shouldn’t change depending on whose name is on the deal.