Donald Trump’s Two Cabinets: A Tale of Two Terms

In his first term, Trump surrounded himself with experienced people who sometimes told him no, and the guardrails often held. In his second, loyalty comes first, and families are paying for it, from measles outbreaks to grounded flights.

· 13 min read

Every president needs people in the room who will tell him the truth, especially when he doesn’t want to hear it. That’s what a cabinet is for. Its members run huge departments, but their most important job is giving the president their best judgment about what will actually work for the country.

Donald Trump is the rare president who has tried it both ways. His two cabinets tell a tale of two terms, and the difference is worth paying attention to, whatever you think of him.

The first cabinet: experience in the room

When Trump took office in 2017, he leaned on people with long records in the jobs they were given: a retired four-star Marine general at Defense, another retired four-star general running Homeland Security and later the White House staff, a former Exxon CEO at State, a former senator as director of national intelligence. Many of them disagreed with him, sometimes loudly, and many of them left or were pushed out. That first term was chaotic. Turnover set records, and nobody should pretend otherwise.

But on some of the biggest calls, experienced advisers pushed back, and it mattered:

  • In 2018, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis resigned in protest over a sudden order to pull every U.S. troop out of Syria. That decision was later reversed.
  • In June 2020, as protests spread, Defense Secretary Mark Esper said publicly that he did not support invoking the Insurrection Act to send active-duty troops into American cities. The president was furious. The troops didn’t go.
  • After the 2020 election, Attorney General Bill Barr, one of the president’s strongest allies, said the Justice Department had not found fraud on a scale that could have changed the result.

You can argue about any one of those people. The point is that each of them brought years of experience to the job and was willing to tell the president no. The country was better off for it.

The second cabinet: loyalty first

The president drew a different lesson from those years. He came to see the pushback as disloyalty, and he built his second team around one test. As a Brookings Institution review of his staffing put it, his team placed a premium on loyalty above all else.

Some second-term picks brought real experience. But the most important security posts went to people whose main qualification was loyalty. A former Fox News host was put in charge of the largest military in the world. His first director of national intelligence, who has since resigned, had little direct experience with intelligence work. The new FBI director had spent years attacking the agency he was chosen to lead.

The results have not been the stability that was promised. In 2026 the president fired his Homeland Security secretary and his attorney general within a month. According to the Washington Post, part of his frustration with the attorney general was her failure to prosecute his political foes. When a cabinet member can lose her job for not going after the president’s opponents, the message to everyone else is clear: independence is a risk, and agreement is safe.

That is the opposite of what a cabinet is for. A secretary who only repeats what the president already thinks adds nothing. The president pays the price for that, and so does everyone else.

The latest choice continues the pattern. Days after voters handed both chambers of Congress to Democrats, the president named Stephen Miller, one of his most combative partisan advisers, as White House chief of staff. The chief of staff sets the tone for how the White House works with Congress. Putting a partisan in that job, right when voters asked both parties to share power, tells Washington that working together isn’t the plan. Partisanship at the top drives partisanship everywhere else, and it makes it harder to get anything done for Utah families on health care, housing, or the border.

What the difference costs

This isn’t abstract. Here’s what it costs.

Measles is back. As of November 12, the CDC had counted 5,412 measles cases this year, the worst outbreak in decades, with 591 people hospitalized and six deaths. International health officials are deciding this month whether the United States has lost the measles-free status it earned in 2000. Utah has been hit hard. More than 700 Utahns have caught measles since our outbreak began in June 2025, and nearly two-thirds of them were kids.

Vaccination rates were slipping before this administration took office, and no single person caused this outbreak. But the nation’s top health official spent decades raising doubts about the measles vaccine. Since taking office, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. fired all 17 members of the CDC’s vaccine advisory panel and replaced them with new members, including vaccine skeptics. Then, in January, his department cut the childhood vaccine schedule from protecting against 17 diseases to 11, without consulting the vaccine panel at all. It took a federal court to stop it. In March, a judge ruled that the new panel was unlawfully appointed, froze the new schedule, and put every vaccine recommendation change since May 2025 on hold while the case continues. When judges have to step in to protect the childhood vaccine schedule, something has gone badly wrong at the top. He has said the measles vaccine prevents the disease, but experts say he has also spread misinformation about its safety. When the person in charge sends mixed signals, parents notice. An experienced public health leader would have put the full weight of the government behind the vaccine from day one.

Air travel came to a halt. On Friday, November 13, the FAA grounded departures nationwide for more than four hours, the longest nationwide stop since 9/11. More than 14,000 flights were canceled on Friday and Saturday, and travelers were still stranded on Sunday. Officials say a contractor’s routine router replacement overloaded the antiquated equipment that runs air traffic control.

Our air traffic system has been aging for decades under presidents of both parties, and the president is right that it needs fixing. But the answer from this administration has too often been to cut, and to hand the cutting to people who didn’t understand the work.

Early in the term, the president gave Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency sweeping power to slash federal jobs. Musk is a brilliant businessman, but he had never run a government agency, and his young staff had no background in why aviation safety rules and jobs exist. According to the New York Times, the president’s own Transportation Secretary, Sean Duffy, confronted Musk in a March 2025 cabinet meeting, saying DOGE staff were trying to lay off air traffic controllers while he was dealing with multiple plane crashes. Musk called it a lie. Duffy said no controllers were fired because he had stopped it. That’s exactly the kind of pushback an experienced adviser should give. This time, it came from inside the cabinet, and it worked.

Others weren’t so lucky. In February 2025, DOGE fired roughly 400 FAA employees. Officials said no controllers were let go, but the cuts included workers hired to maintain radar, landing, and navigation equipment. In May, the FAA lowered its target for air traffic controllers by about 2,000, even though the agency has been short thousands of controllers for years, and the controllers’ union said it had no say.

Special education is getting the same treatment. Many Utahns agree that Washington shouldn’t run our schools, and that’s a fair debate to have. But the way the Education Department is being taken apart follows the same pattern. Secretary Linda McMahon, a former WWE executive who ran the Small Business Administration in the first term, was tasked with dismantling the department. By the end of 2025, about half of its 4,133 employees were gone through layoffs, buyouts, and early retirements. During last fall’s shutdown, the department laid off almost everyone in the office that oversees special education and nearly $15 billion a year in funding for students with disabilities. A federal judge blocked those layoffs. Then in June, the department signed an agreement to hand day-to-day management of special education to HHS, even though only Congress can abolish the department, and Congress never voted to.

Special education isn’t a nice-to-have program. It’s a promise written into federal law, and about 90,000 Utah students count on it. Moving it around without understanding how it works puts those kids at risk.

Basic judgment matters too. Experience isn’t just about knowing policy. It’s about knowing how the job is done. Three more examples:

  • Strike plans on a group chat. In March 2025, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth shared the timing of U.S. airstrikes in Yemen in a Signal group chat on his personal phone, a chat that turned out to include a journalist. The Pentagon’s own inspector general later found he risked compromising sensitive information that could have endangered American troops, and that he shared similar details in a second chat that included his wife and brother. The watchdog also found he had the authority to declassify the information, and Hegseth called the report an exoneration. But any experienced defense leader knows you don’t send strike timing over a commercial app.
  • A sign-off rule during a flood. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem required that every contract and grant over $100,000 cross her desk. When deadly floods hit central Texas in July 2025, CNN and the Washington Post reported that FEMA search-and-rescue teams weren’t authorized until 72 hours after the flooding began. FEMA’s acting head disputed that the rule caused delays. Either way, anyone who has managed a disaster knows that the first 72 hours are when lives are saved, and that’s no time for extra paperwork.
  • The FBI jet as a personal ride. FBI Director Kash Patel and his girlfriend used an FBI Gulfstream jet to fly to a country music concert in Philadelphia, according to the New York Times, and a government ethics watchdog called for an investigation into his personal trips on bureau jets. Leaders who understand public service know that taxpayer resources aren’t perks.

It isn’t yet clear whether any of the FAA cuts played a role in Friday’s failure. But across all of these, the pattern is the problem. Cutting the people who keep an old system running, on the advice of people who don’t know why those jobs exist, is exactly what happens when loyalty and slogans matter more than experience. Before you cut something, you should understand why it’s there.

What we should want from any president

This isn’t about one president or one party. It’s a standard we should hold every president to, including the next one, whoever that is.

  • Pick people who know the job. Experience isn’t everything, but running the Pentagon, the FBI, or our intelligence agencies is no place to learn on the fly.
  • Reward honest advice. The best leaders keep people around who will tell them they’re wrong. Every good business works that way, and so should the White House.
  • Take the Senate’s job seriously. The Constitution gives the Senate the power of advice and consent for a reason. Senators of both parties should ask one question about every nominee: will this person tell the president the truth?
  • Leave room for the other side. A chief of staff sets the tone for the whole government. In divided government, that tone should be “let’s get something done,” not “let’s fight.”

Utahns understand this. Our own governor took “Disagree Better” national, and the idea fits who we are. We know that the people who help us most are the ones willing to say, “I don’t think that’s a good idea.” A president deserves advisers like that, and so does the country.

Two cabinets, side by side

Here is the president’s very first team, as it stood in 2017 before any changes, next to the people holding the same jobs today. Judge for yourself. Not every first-term pick was a policy expert, and not every current one lacks experience. But the overall difference is hard to miss.

Job First term (2017) Today (November 2026)
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson: CEO of ExxonMobil, decades of negotiating with foreign governments Marco Rubio: 14 years in the U.S. Senate, including the Foreign Relations and Intelligence committees
Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis: retired four-star Marine general, led U.S. Central Command, 44 years in uniform Pete Hegseth: former Fox News weekend host and Army National Guard officer, had never run a large organization
Attorney General Jeff Sessions: 20 years in the U.S. Senate, former U.S. attorney and Alabama attorney general Todd Blanche: former federal prosecutor and the president’s personal defense lawyer, confirmed 50 to 49
Homeland Security John Kelly: retired four-star Marine general, led U.S. Southern Command Markwayne Mullin: U.S. senator and plumbing-company owner, no law enforcement or disaster experience; replaced Kristi Noem
Health and Human Services Tom Price: orthopedic surgeon, 12 years in Congress, chaired the House Budget Committee Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: environmental lawyer and longtime vaccine critic, no medical or public health background
Education Betsy DeVos: school-choice advocate and philanthropist, no public school experience Linda McMahon: former WWE executive, ran the Small Business Administration, one year on Connecticut’s state school board
Transportation Elaine Chao: former Labor Secretary and Deputy Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy: former congressman and Fox Business host
Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats: former senator on the Senate Intelligence Committee, ambassador to Germany Jay Clayton: former SEC chairman and U.S. attorney, no intelligence background; replaced Tulsi Gabbard
FBI Director Christopher Wray (first pick, 2017): former head of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division Kash Patel: former federal prosecutor and congressional staffer, never worked at the FBI
White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus: chairman of the Republican National Committee Stephen Miller: longtime presidential speechwriter and immigration adviser

James Comey was FBI director when the president took office in 2017, but he was an Obama appointee, so the table shows the president’s own first pick. Current officeholders are as of November 16, 2026.