We Can’t Fix the Debt by Fighting Over the Smallest Slice
Washington’s budget fights, from shutdowns to DOGE, are almost all about one slice of spending that makes up about 13% of the budget. The deficit is bigger than that entire slice. A serious plan has to include the big programs and defense, and ask those at the top to pay more.
Every few months, Washington has the same fight. Lawmakers threaten a shutdown, someone promises to cut waste, and everyone goes home claiming they got tough on spending. Then the national debt keeps climbing.
There’s a reason. Nearly all of those fights are about the smallest slice of the budget. To see why, it helps to start with two words that get mixed up all the time.
The debt and the deficit aren’t the same thing
The deficit is how much more the government spends than it takes in during a single year. In fiscal 2026, which ended September 30, the government spent about $7.4 trillion and collected about $5.4 trillion, leaving a deficit of about $2.0 trillion.
The debt is the running total of every deficit we’ve ever run, minus the rare years we paid some back. It passed $40 trillion in August, double what it was in 2017. About $32 trillion of that is borrowed from investors at home and abroad. The rest is money the government owes its own trust funds, like Social Security’s.
Think of a credit card. The deficit is how much more you charge than you pay off each month. The debt is the balance. You can’t pay down the balance while you’re still adding $2 trillion to it every year. We have to close the deficit before we can do anything about the debt.
We haven’t balanced the budget since 2001. Deficits jumped in the Great Recession and again during COVID, and they’ve never come back down to where they were. We’re now borrowing about $2 trillion a year in a growing economy, with no crisis to blame.
Revenue matters just as much. Revenue covered all of our spending only once in the last 45 years, in the late 1990s, after budget deals in 1990 and 1993 raised taxes and a strong economy did the rest. Every major tax cut since 1981 was followed by taxes covering a smaller share of what we spend. Recessions did a lot of the damage as well, but the pattern is hard to miss. Today taxes cover about 73 cents of every dollar the government spends.
And the balance isn’t free. Interest on the debt cost more than $1.1 trillion last year, more than the entire Defense Department. Every year we wait, that bill gets bigger.
Mandatory and discretionary: the two kinds of spending
To understand the budget, you need to know that federal spending comes in two kinds.
Mandatory spending goes out automatically under laws already on the books. If you qualify, you get it, and Congress doesn’t vote on it each year. This includes Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food assistance, veterans’ disability benefits, and federal retirement. Interest on the debt works the same way. We owe it, so we pay it.
Discretionary spending is the part Congress has to approve every year through spending bills. It comes in two pieces:
- Defense: the military and related national security programs.
- Everything else: air traffic control, the FBI, border patrol, national parks, medical research, veterans’ hospitals, embassies, food safety inspectors, and most of what people picture when they think of “the government.”
Here’s how the money breaks down, and how we pay for it.
Every fight is over the red slice
That red slice on the left, everything outside defense that Congress votes on each year, is about 13% of federal spending. It’s roughly $1 trillion.
It’s also where nearly every budget fight happens. Shutdowns are fights over the yearly spending bills. Calls to “cut waste, fraud, and abuse” almost always point at it. DOGE went after it, too. But a New York Times review of DOGE’s 40 largest savings claims found only 12 that appeared accurate. The cuts Congress actually voted to lock in came to about $9 billion, less than half a percent of a $2 trillion deficit. Total spending went up anyway.
Now do the math. The deficit is about $2 trillion. The red slice is about $1 trillion. If we eliminated every dollar of it, every park, every FBI agent, every air traffic controller, every medical research grant, we would still borrow about $1 trillion a year. Eliminate the whole defense budget too, and we’d still be short.
Cutting the red slice while growing defense doesn’t close the gap either. The president’s latest budget would cut nondefense spending by $2.6 trillion over ten years while adding $2.4 trillion for defense. On net, that’s barely a dent.
Waste is real, and we should go after it. But anyone who tells you we can balance the budget by cutting “the bureaucracy” either hasn’t looked at the numbers or is hoping you won’t.
A serious plan has to include the big programs
The fastest-growing parts of the budget are Social Security, health care, and interest. Over the next decade, those areas plus veterans’ programs will drive about 90% of the growth in federal spending. Any budget plan that leaves them off the table isn’t serious.
That doesn’t mean cutting checks for people who’ve spent their lives paying in. It means being honest about where the money has to come from:
- Social Security: the Social Security ideas on this site keep benefits whole for everyone 50 and older and keep the retirement age at 67. They pay for it with one lower rate on every paycheck and no cap, so the highest earners pay the same rate on all of their income that a teacher or a nurse pays on theirs.
- Health care: the Medicaid ideas ask business income above $400,000 a year to pay the same 3.8% tax that wages already pay. The Medicare buy-in is built to pay for itself through premiums.
- Taxes: the tax ideas close loopholes at the very top, and no household earning under $200,000 pays a dollar more.
Asking the people who’ve done best in this economy to pay a little more is a fair trade for keeping the promises we’ve made to everyone else.
Defense has to be part of it too
A strong military matters, and Utah is proud of its role in it, from Hill Air Force Base to our National Guard. But the Pentagon has failed its financial audit eight years in a row. It’s the only one of the government’s 24 major agencies that has never passed. Defense budgets should be held to the same standard as everything else, including a clean audit and weapons programs that stay on budget. The budget ideas lay out how.
The bottom line
The deficit is a math problem, and math doesn’t care about slogans. If we keep fighting over 13% of the budget and calling it fiscal responsibility, the debt will keep growing no matter who’s in charge.
Fixing it means doing the hard things: protecting the programs people count on by making sure the people at the top pay their share, holding defense to the same standard as everything else, and closing the deficit so we can finally start paying down the debt. That’s not a Republican plan or a Democratic plan. It’s just the math.