A President Needs Advisers Who Can Say No

In his first term, President Trump surrounded himself with experienced people who sometimes told him no, and the guardrails often held. In his second, loyalty came first. Naming Stephen Miller chief of staff tells us bipartisanship is off the table. Any president, of any party, is better served by advisers who give honest advice.

· 5 min read

Every president needs people in the room who will tell him the truth, especially when he doesn’t want to hear it. That’s what a cabinet is for. Its members run huge departments, but their most important job is giving the president their best judgment about what will actually work for the country.

President Trump has now tried it both ways. The difference is worth paying attention to, whatever you think of him.

The first term: experience in the room

When Trump took office in 2017, he leaned on people with long records in the jobs they were given: a retired four-star Marine general at Defense, another retired four-star general running Homeland Security and later the White House staff, a former Exxon CEO at State, a former senator as director of national intelligence. Many of them disagreed with him, sometimes loudly, and many of them left or were pushed out. That first term was chaotic. Turnover set records, and nobody should pretend otherwise.

But on some of the biggest calls, experienced advisers pushed back, and it mattered:

  • In 2018, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis resigned in protest over a sudden order to pull every U.S. troop out of Syria. That decision was later reversed.
  • In June 2020, as protests spread, Defense Secretary Mark Esper said publicly that he did not support invoking the Insurrection Act to send active-duty troops into American cities. The president was furious. The troops didn’t go.
  • After the 2020 election, Attorney General Bill Barr, one of the president’s strongest allies, said the Justice Department had not found fraud on a scale that could have changed the result.

You can argue about any one of those people. The point is that each of them brought years of experience to the job and was willing to tell the president no. The country was better off for it.

The second term: loyalty first

The president drew a different lesson from those years. He came to see the pushback as disloyalty, and he built his second team around one test. As a Brookings Institution review of his staffing put it, his team placed a premium on loyalty above all else.

Some second-term picks brought real experience. But the most important security posts went to people whose main qualification was loyalty. A former Fox News host was put in charge of the largest military in the world. The new director of national intelligence had little direct experience with intelligence work. The new FBI director had spent years attacking the agency he was chosen to lead.

The results have not been the stability that was promised. In 2026 the president fired his Homeland Security secretary and his attorney general within a month. According to the Washington Post, part of his frustration with the attorney general was her failure to prosecute his political foes. When a cabinet member can lose her job for not going after the president’s opponents, the message to everyone else is clear: independence is a risk, and agreement is safe.

That is the opposite of what a cabinet is for. A secretary who only repeats what the president already thinks adds nothing. The president pays the price for that, and so does everyone else.

Stephen Miller sends a clear message

Then came the choice of a new chief of staff. Days after voters handed both chambers of Congress to Democrats, the president named Stephen Miller to run the White House.

The chief of staff decides who gets in the door, what reaches the president’s desk, and how the White House deals with Congress. With divided government starting in January, that job should go to someone who can build bridges. Instead it went to one of the most combative partisans in Washington. During the midterm campaign, Miller called Democrats “extremists, freaks and America-hating lunatics.” The Associated Press reported that the shake-up signals a president who is resisting a conciliatory approach to the new Congress.

Voters just asked Washington to share power. Picking Miller as chief of staff tells them the White House isn’t interested in working together. That’s a loss for Utah families who need things done on health care, housing, and the border, none of which can pass without both parties.

What we should want from any president

This isn’t about one president or one party. It’s a standard we should hold every president to, including the next one, whoever that is.

  • Pick people who know the job. Experience isn’t everything, but running the Pentagon, the FBI, or our intelligence agencies is no place to learn on the fly.
  • Reward honest advice. The best leaders keep people around who will tell them they’re wrong. Every good business works that way, and so should the White House.
  • Take the Senate’s job seriously. The Constitution gives the Senate the power of advice and consent for a reason. Senators of both parties should ask one question about every nominee: will this person tell the president the truth?
  • Leave room for the other side. A chief of staff sets the tone for the whole government. In divided government, that tone should be “let’s get something done,” not “let’s fight.”

Utahns understand this. Our own governor took “Disagree Better” national, and the idea fits who we are. We know that the people who help us most are the ones willing to say, “I don’t think that’s a good idea.” A president deserves advisers like that, and so does the country.